What's new

A Long and Philosophical Post: Game VS Sense of Self

Bboy100

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jan 2, 2015
Messages
1,107
Hi guys,

So recently, I started going back to therapy in order to resolve a few personal issues of mine. One thing that came up was my dating life. I mentioned that I wasn't really satisfied with the women (or lack thereof) in my life. For that reason, I work on dating as a skill (I didn't mention the pickup community or GC or anything like that). His response was that therapeutically speaking, that's not a very good idea. In other words, having women in my life is not really a solution for the problem. The real problem is deeper than that. He mentioned that instead, it would be better for me to work on myself. That is to say, my beliefs, my sense of confidence/ self-worth, my outlooks, the way I think perceive and analyze things, other aspects of my life etc.

Why am I posting this here? Well the discussion I wanted to create was this:
A. Do you guys believe that working on and getting good at game as a skill is a solution to feelings of loneliness/girl-related depression? Or do we need to be ok with and live an overall happy single life before we even start trying to bring women into it? Furthermore, how practical is it to even bring women into our lives if we don't feel good about ourselves? Like, if I feel depressed or anxious or otherwise dissatisfied, and I don't take care of those things first, do I even have a real shot at creating the right vibe/energy/charisma to bring women into my life in the first place?

B. It seems that most of the stuff he mentioned about sense of self is what the pickup community would coin "inner game" something which is not talked about nearly as often as outer game here at girlschase. I know Chase mentions that he believes inner game develops through actions. That is, once I get good enough at outer game, the correct inner-game related mindsets will naturally come.

However, this does raise a certain concern of mine. To better understand it, lets imagine a man who is depressed/utterly hates himself/sees no worth in himself/has no self confidence etc. It seems very unlikely that such a man would ever bring himself to approach a women. But for the sake of example, lets say he does approach. Even if he would normally be a fantastic conversationalist, his mindsets about himself/ low self-confidence is likely to cause him to be stuck in his own head- inhibiting him from utilizing said conversation skills in the first place. Which would likely cause said approach to go nowhere. As long as he retains these negative mindsets, most all subsequent approaches are also likely to bring no results. Because of this, I feel like we might necessarily need to have our inner game taken care of...at least to some degree before it would be reasonable a goal for us to even start trying to apply the outer game principles taught here at GC. That is to say, once we are psychologically capable of taking the actions prescribed by GC, then yes, Chase is right. Stronger and better mindsets will develop as we get better at game as a skill. However, if we are psychologically incapable of taking said actions, all the outer game information/motivation in the world is useless to us.

Also, I feel that its possible that getting good at outer game will only create proper mindsets in the realm of seduction. But they may not transfer throughout our lifes as a whole. Whereas, I feel like working on inner game would be more applicable to anything we do in our lives.

To further illustrate, here's an example from my life: I'm a very good athlete. In most athletic events, I know I'm going to perform well. I know I can compete. In other words, I have the skill, I've done the "outer game" type stuff (i.e. I've hit the gym, I play a lot of sports, I work on my athleticism etc). So I naturally feel very confident about myself and my abilities in situations like these. But this confidence doesn't at all transfer to other areas of my life (such as dating).

Could working on game be the same way? What I mean is, could it be that It creates confidence/good mindsets, but only in the realm of seduction.

Because I know that if I work on myself as a person directly, instead of on a specific skill, my ability to "handle whatever life throws at me" will increase in all areas. Not in just one.
 

PrettyDecent

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Mar 2, 2013
Messages
865
Hey Bboy,

If you're in a depression, yeah, definitely best to rid yourself of those negative thought cycles before moving on!

Bboy100 said:
Could working on game be the same way? What I mean is, could it be that It creates confidence/good mindsets, but only in the realm of seduction.

I'd say when you become really good with people in general (seduction included), it becomes pretty natural to be "self-confident" almost all of the time. Ever since I "broke through" in seduction, I haven't really felt much self-esteem issues since.

Of course, this only partially has to do with just the seductions themselves. I think a lot of people get depressed because of a social problem they have - whether it's not being able to replace a girlfriend, or not having the type of friends or social life they wish they had. They feel lonely. When you master the social arts, those aren't issues anymore.

Bboy100 said:
Because I know that if I work on myself as a person directly, instead of on a specific skill, my ability to "handle whatever life throws at me" will increase in all areas. Not in just one.

How does "working on yourself" differ than this? What concrete actions are you looking to take? What's your end goal, how long will it take, and how will you know when it's done? What's the concrete evidence to know its working?

If you can answer those questions, then your all set to go.

On the subject of therapists - I've considered having one myself. I do get kinda frustrated if I don't see progress in my life or if there's something really stressing me out, I would like to take it out somehow. Poor fella at least would get paid for it! So I get where you're coming from.

But the other thing I've thought about is this: are they actually a good influence when it comes to self-improvement? They might actually be awesome. But my standards are strict: they must be living the life I want to live/be amazing at this skill I'm looking to learn. Otherwise, I'd need to filter some of the advice I heard.

Hope this helps, bud!

~Nick
 
a good date brings a smile to your lips... and hers

Drck

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Feb 14, 2013
Messages
1,488
Well, if you have personal issues I would start working on it first before serious dating. It seems that your current solution is to find a girl, and that is how you get over your problems. That is a wrong solution, you will only bring your problems into the potential relationship. You expect the girl to make you happy, to take care of you, to ease your problems. And you might find girl like that, the problem is that you (and she as well) will become codependent on each other.

Going into the relationship with this mind set (I am depressed/down because I don't have any girl, and once I found a good girl I will be happy) is not healthy. She will not make you happy, you will only shift your problems onto her.

You know, there is a difference between boys and men. Men are more independent, they are self-sufficient, they don't need anybody (and anything) to be happy. They don't need titles to be happy, they don't need approval of others, they don't need money or anything else to be happy. They already grew up, meaning that they don't need mama to take care of them.

Girls don't want boys. Ok, maybe when they are young and silly they don't really care, but once they start thinking more seriously about their lives it changes. They want men. She doesn't want to be mama to her BF, she doesn't want to take care of her mate. She wants somebody more mature, more independent, more emotionally stable, somebody who is not clingy and needy for woman - so she can take care of her (potential) kids...

Feeling depressed, anxious, dissatisfied is what creates bad vibes at first place. Girls are much more sensitive than guys, they can "read" you very well no matter how much you learn to fake sexy vibes, being happy, having fantastic conversations and so on. These bad vibes are the cause why you don't have girls at your life at first place.

It is like a cycle, you are not happy because you don't have any girl, and because you don't have girl you are not happy. The cycle just feeds itself.

So find happiness, independence, maturity, confidence, self-esteem first. If you don't like yourself, if you hate yourself, if you hate your life - can other people and especially girls like you? They really can't because you are sending out bad vibes. Change those vibes first. Learn to be happy without 'things', and learn to be happy without having a girl in your life.

At the same time, I wouldn't give up on girls. You want to keep improving your inner and outer game at the same time, you want to attack the bad vibes from every possible angle. You can start slow, with what you know and what you have - talking to girls, improving conversations, going out, making friends... So it doesn't have to be either inner or outer game that you are working on - it can be both at the same time...
 

Lotus

Modern Human
Modern Human
Joined
Nov 12, 2014
Messages
624
Hey Bboy,

"inner game" something which is not talked about nearly as often as outer game here at girlschase

I think you underestimate the amount of material on inner game.

The whole mindsets tab is inner game because inner game directly refers to everything going on inside your head. In my opinion, the mindsets and underlying principles are most valuable information here because they don't just apply to pick up they can be applied to anything.

I'll use sports as an example:

Persistence- you don't stop shooting because you miss or it gets saved
Mental toughness- when your team goes down you don't stop playing. If in your head you say fuck we are going to lose.... then you will lose.
Outcome independence- losing a match sucks/losing a girl sucks but after the fact you revisit your mistakes, correct them and look to improve.

Another grossly overused example of fantastic inner game: How many times did Thomas Edison fail on the light bulb? He never gave up because his mental was strong.

No one can teach you mental strength/inner game... they only can show you the path but you own inner fire and desire to succeed is required. Does your hunger burn brighter then the next guy?

Inner game/mental strength is how you react to what the world throws at you. That's all it is.

I do think a big part of that is how you were raised and whether your parents taught helped you move on after something bad happen or if they complained with you( Do you blame a loss on the poor refereeing? or do you say I could have been better?)

Could working on game be the same way? What I mean is, could it be that It creates confidence/good mindsets, but only in the realm of seduction

The principles and foundations you use to create confidence and good mindsets can be applied anywhere. You just have to dig deep inside yourself and find out what foundation you are missing.

Because I know that if I work on myself as a person directly, instead of on a specific skill, my ability to "handle whatever life throws at me" will increase in all areas. Not in just one.

My friend, you are further along the path then I think you believe for you are asking all of the right questions.

I don't know where to put this but on a side note:

When speaking about mental strength the word affirmations gets brought up a lot here, "all girls want sex, girls love dick, I am hot shit, She wants to fuck me." Whether or not it is true it is very powerful..... but affirmations aren't only used on your ego.... why not "I will not give up, no matter what happens I will push on, I will not be defeated, I will not surrender." Are those not affirmations as well?

Affirmations illicit an emotional response in example 1: confidence, arrogance. In example 2: anger, motivation.

The summer before my collegiate senior soccer season I stayed on campus and trained. Every time I ran I used affirmations, in a sense, to push my physical limits. When I was near exhaustion and nearing the last couple sprints/laps I would tell myself, "Fuck Messiah! Fuck Messiah! Fuck Messiah!"(our rival school) It triggered an emotion response- anger- and I was able to push myself further then I thought I could.
 

bassman

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Aug 21, 2013
Messages
30
Hey Bboy, not sure if you've read Chase's article on depression yet but here it is:

https://www.girlschase.com/content/how-o ... depression

Although I have never had a serious problem with depression, this article helped me with the small bouts that I have had. It has also helped me console friends who have gone through depression. Even if you have already read it, it's good to give it a second go over.
 

Bboy100

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jan 2, 2015
Messages
1,107
The principles and foundations you use to create confidence and good mindsets can be applied anywhere. You just have to dig deep inside yourself and find out what foundation you are missing.

This is true, to a degree. But I feel like in terms of socializing, its a little different in many respects. Lets take my example of how I'm a good athlete. I started out being very very unconfident. And also pretty bad at sports. Even so, I was still physically capeable of practicing. Like, no matter how shitty I felt about myself, I can always shoot a basketball and get better at it. As I got better, my confidence also improved (in that area of life). I was 12 years old at the time. I wasn't aware of what "self confidence" or any inner game related stuff even is. The only "principle" I had was to keep practicing cause I like playing bball. Later on, I did the same exact thing with many other sports and with weightlifting. This improvement of confidence was not even something I was aware of. It was just a byproduct of what I was naturally doing.

Whereas, in socializing of any form, there is an admission price to pay. And that price is to have enough inner game that you can at least start to apply the material. For example, I have to be confident enough to at least be able to force myself to approach. And I also have to have a clear enough head to at least be able to hold a conversation at least somewhat normally (i.e. not be tripping over every word because I'm so nervous). And so fourth. So I feel like my principle of "just practice harder and more than the other guys" doesn't really work as effectively here. ..At least not at the very start.

How does "working on yourself" differ than this? What concrete actions are you looking to take? What's your end goal, how long will it take, and how will you know when it's done? What's the concrete evidence to know its working?

If you can answer those questions, then your all set to go.

I don't know yet. We only briefly mentioned the concept of working on yourself last time I saw him. We're going to talk about it more in depth next time I see him. Perhaps a lot of the things he tells me will be similar to what GC advocates. And yeah, obviously if we don't create an outline for concrete actions, then all this Philosophical talk is pretty useless. In hindsight, maybe I should have posted this after I had more an idea of exactly what we're doing.


A few other overarching themes:

1. I may have given you guys the wrong impression. I am a little dissatisfied with the way things are right now, but I doubt I'm depressed from a clinical standpoint. I certainly have some mindset changes to make but I don't hate myself or anything like that. The example I brought up in my second paragraph was completely hypothetical, designed to get my point across. I probably should have written this in a way which leaves me/my personal life out completely. I feel that the forums are not a place I should be using to talk about non-social arts/seduction related personal problems. So I apologize for alluding to my therapy to begin with.

2. On affirmations: I definitely think they are very powerful tools. Back when I wrestled competitively, I used them very often when I felt tired, exhausted, beat. They are what motivated me to keep going and to become better, stronger and more skilled than the other guys. In fact, they were so effective for me that I developed a literal fear of losing. Although one thing to note is that they were very natural and organic. Like, when I felt tired and like I was gonna give up, I always had the thought "fuck that, I know the other guy's working just as hard, I can't quit" cross my mind. Whereas, I just recently started using them purposefully and consciously for my social life. So naturally, they're a little more artificial (i.e. I stand in front of the mirror and read something that I've written down as opposed to having a thought which naturally popped into my head). Either way, I'm still experimenting with them, so we'll see how it goes.


3. I can see learning social skills in general will also improve one's sense of self as well. Socializing is an expression of one's self. As such, improving at it by definition means to improve yourself. Thank you (posters) for clarifying that.

4. Yeah I figured, taking care of my own emotional needs first is probably a more effective road to self-fulfillment than trying to bring girls into my life as a substitute. Just wanted to see what you guys had to say on the topic. So thank you for those posts Drck and Nick.

5. Bassman, I've read the article on depression, definitely has some good tips which I try to use whenever I'm feeling down.
Franco, thank you for that article. Having a sense of purpose in life is something I've been looking into. I feel that if I had more of a sense of purpose, I would have less of an inclination to define my worth as a person by my success with women. Hence this post. I particularly like the part where it talks about fulfilling biological and emotional needs prior to logical ones. I finally understand why I have very little emotional attachment to the things which I believe (on a logical level) are most important to me atm (i.e. to finish school, get a good job etc.).

Also, I apologize if I'm writing some stuff which isn't exactly accurate. I'm only trying to gain a better understanding of these things. I'd also like to note that by no means am I saying I know better than what this site is saying or that the writers are wrong. I'm simply looking to challenge some of the ideas here in hopes that my objections will be overcome, and that in the end, I have a better understanding of the concepts as a whole.
 

Lotus

Modern Human
Modern Human
Joined
Nov 12, 2014
Messages
624
This is true, to a degree. But I feel like in terms of socializing, its a little different in many respects. Lets take my example of how I'm a good athlete. I started out being very very unconfident. And also pretty bad at sports. Even so, I was still physically capeable of practicing. Like, no matter how shitty I felt about myself, I can always shoot a basketball and get better at it. As I got better, my confidence also improved (in that area of life). I was 12 years old at the time. I wasn't aware of what "self confidence" or any inner game related stuff even is. The only "principle" I had was to keep practicing cause I like playing bball. Later on, I did the same exact thing with many other sports and with weightlifting. This improvement of confidence was not even something I was aware of. It was just a byproduct of what I was naturally doing.

Whereas, in socializing of any form, there is an admission price to pay. And that price is to have enough inner game that you can at least start to apply the material. For example, I have to be confident enough to at least be able to force myself to approach. And I also have to have a clear enough head to at least be able to hold a conversation at least somewhat normally (i.e. not be tripping over every word because I'm so nervous). And so fourth. So I feel like my principle of "just practice harder and more than the other guys" doesn't really work as effectively here. ..At least not at the very start.

"just practice harder and more than the other guys"

Instead of practice harder it should be practice smarter. Take your basketball example.

Yes, the more time you shoot a basketball the better you will get, but what if your form is shit? If you pick up a basketball one day and decide to play without any coaching your going to miss fundamental steps such as hand postioning, squaring up to the hoop, release and follow through. If I wish to be any good at basketball and I skip those steps and go strait to shooting three pointers... progress will be slow as fuck.

An approach is the exact same thing as a shot. You are hoping to score. Before you can approach you have to be able to hold eye contact, hold a convesation, etc..... the fundamentals. This is why the guys here have put together the noob assignment. You don't immediatley begin to approach thats a rediculous expectation. First day you go out and practice eye contact, then saying hi, etc.

But i completely agree socializing is harder because you have to let go of your ego
 
Top