What's new

Date with a girl 15 years younger... What went wrong?

Marty

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Messages
1,539
I've been wondering about this for just over a week, and it's time now to stop wondering and start putting it into writing in the hope that the collective expertise of the more advanced fellows here can set me straight.

Though I had a modest amount of experience (and success) with women in my youth, I still place myself firmly in the "beginner" category in view of the awe-inspiring standards of this site's authors. But over the course of 30+ cold approaches in recent weeks, I have refined my fundamentals - details are surely unnecessary, everyone here knows what I'm talking about - to a degree that I move with greater general confidence among my existing social circle. (That occurrence will be unsurprising to readers who have undertaken the same process.) In this post, the particular aspect of social circle I am referring to is my occupational life... i.e. the people I see on a working day at the office.

So... a few weeks back, while I was minding my own business getting a cup of tea in the kitchen, a young woman who just happened to join our organization at about the time I was getting into the swing of things and putting into practice what I read on this site, and who has been smiling at me in the corridors ever since, found a startlingly obvious way to get near me, bringing in a plate of homemade oatmeal cookies and asking if I'd like one. Now, naturally priding myself in my low body mass index and "athletic" body composition figure, I normally avoid such stuff, but given the circumstances, I accepted with good grace and allowed myself to be briefly diverted into conversation. I do make exceptions occasionally when circumstances warrant it :)

The girl - let's call her Paula... it's not her name, but if I can be Marty, she can surely be Paula; the name suits her - is an intern in the company where I am a director. She is 15 years my junior: in her early twenties while I'm in my late thirties. About right, to my way of thinking. Anyway, minding my intentionally averted body language and sidelong eye contact, I conspiratorially told Paula (rather elegantly, I thought) that while I wasn't much of a one for chatting in the office (thus cutting a potentially hazardous interaction short), if she'd like to join me for coffee some day, OUTSIDE the office (emphasis as written!), she'd be welcome. She accepted with enthusiasm, I said I'd email her, and I hauled ass. Thus smoothly setting up a date, making it abundantly clear that it was non-professional territory, and nicely making it look like it had been her idea all along.

Now the great beauty of doing stuff with Paula is that I don't have to "disqualify myself as a boyfriend". I can't be anyone's boyfriend, in fact, because I am married. And Paula knows this... not only does she know it, but in her exquisitely refined feminine nosiness and man-shocking peripheral vision, she has seen me at a city event and at a company function with my attractive wife, even though I could swear she never looked in our direction, and she enjoys every opportunity to pointedly remind me of the fact: "Yes, I saw you too, was that your FAMILY with you?" / "Did you go on vacation with your FAMILY? How lovely..." and so forth. All good fun.

At any rate, on the appointed day last week we downed tools at 4 p.m. and met outside as conspiratorially arranged by me, and went to have tea at a local cafe.

Well, dear readers, you'll be proud to hear that I well and truly went to town, as you have every right to expect. Placing my hand on the small of her back about 2 seconds into our interaction, I commanded her to step in a southerly direction and steered her that way to make sure she got the message. Before we'd crossed the first street, I informed her that while she was "obviously very attractive" I knew nothing else about her whatever and she had better start telling me about herself. We sat in that cafe for two hours and I deep dived, invited her to share her dreams, her ambitions, asked her who were the most influential people in her life, what she loved best... I complimented sincerely, I touched, I paused, I held her gaze... in short, a fully executed operation. She even told me she had never had a boyfriend. Can you believe that? The only bit missing was that I damn well should have asked to taste her tea. It was a vanilla Chai or some such girly drink that I've never tried, and most likely never will, so I'd have had the perfect excuse. And I couldn't ask her to come sit next to me, because I screwed up the locking-in upon arrival. Need to work on compliance big-time.

Well, in amongst all this deep-diving lark, she shared a shocking fact with me. Shocking, that is, given the context that I had been implying all along, with very little subtlety, that my intentions were to do unspeakable things with her. Discussing her plans for postgraduate study, she mentioned that she wanted to attend a seminary, to research the potential for impact of Christian Scripture on people who seek to put their lives in order. I kid you not.

Well, of course, you have to try to be relatable and enable her to identify and whatnot. So, even though I'm quite comfortable in my sunny, carefree atheism, I echoed her views to an extent, avoiding insincere spiritual or supernatural language, saying that we can always learn from the ancients, human nature doesn't change, many problems have been addressed more or less satisfactorily by our ancestors, etc.

I decided it was time to move her. I asked her to accompany me for a walk in the park opposite, to which she readily agreed. This I saw as a good compliance indicator, as she had previously stated her intention to get home early and finish a thesis paper. As we walked, I raised the question of why she had not had a boyfriend: did the guys simply not measure up? I felt it was important to broach relationship issues. She said she hadn't felt ready for it. I invited her to sit with me on a bench, and as we sat in the setting sun, I asked whether the religious views she had expressed earlier indicated a conservative stance toward the issue of relations between men and women. All I can say from her body language is that she seemed to be expecting a question of this sort.

She began reeling off a string of feminine-sounding concerns regarding commitment, values, sharing etc. etc. and I decided it was time, gently but firmly, to get her onto more productive territory. I asked her about more informal relations, developing a feel for one's preferences, skills etc. She seemed non-committal.

I had figured a possible line of approach: "Ever kissed a guy?", followed by "Want to try?" and well and truly invading her personal space. But first, I wanted to get a read on the picture so far. I asked, "Do you like talking with me?"

Well, I was unprepared for the response. She answered: "Yes, you're a good friend."

I know, I should have kept my cool. But frankly I was thrown into confusion by the contradiction between what she had said and the opposing indicators from her body language and repeated compliance. Not to mention the Scripture stuff thrown into the mix. I responded too quickly, reflexively: "A friend? That's all?" To which she replied an emphatic "Yes". Perhaps through gritted teeth, I was too shocked to be able to tell.

I figured it was over. I wasn't at all confident I could recover or push through, and I didn't really want any employment-related blowback from being too persistent (and failing) although I doubt that would have really been an issue. I walked her back to the parking garage, making neutral conversation; on parting I kissed her on the cheek and thanked her for her honesty. She looked a little taken aback, but I was unable to read the situation.

What is your opinion, fellow bloggers? Should I have persisted, or did I make the right call to bail out and save embarrassment?
 

mkivtt

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Jul 29, 2013
Messages
86
Long story man. But I think you did the right thing. You could have tried kissing her if it wasn't someone who works at your company... but if you HAD kissed her and she clearly had different intentions (remember, young and naive) you could have found yourself with a pink slip tomorrow. How would you explain that to your wife?

I think it's a terrible idea doing anything with women at work unless you are ABSOLUTELY sure there is attraction. And that's not something I would be certain of after one "date," even it's over two hours in length, unless she specifically gave you every IOI in the book. And since this is a young naive girl, that probably wasn't the case, and many IOIs were probably made unaware she was doing them.

You could ask her out to do something again the next time you run into her and gauge her reaction.
- If she's clearly frightened or cool, then it's time to tone it down a notch and maybe just grab some coffee at the break area instead of going somewhere, or maybe just some small chat right there to reassure her and then calling it a day. After that you can try to escalate again in the future, if she opens up and shows more IOIs. If not, call it a day.
- If she shows interest, then maybe she was just taken back. Remember, she might be totally new to this, be a virgin, etc. She may just have needed a little time to process what happened and accept the fact that you hit on her and found her attractive. If this is the case, you can repeat what you did before, but before kissing her try one of the "is she ready to kiss" stragies: gaze at her eyes-nose-mouth, brush against her hair, lean in closer, put her hand on your thigh, etc.

Good luck, it'll be tricky.
 
you miss 100% of the shots you don't take

Marty

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Messages
1,539
Thanks mkivtt for taking the trouble to read what I agree is a long story.

You're absolutely right, when I reflect on it... the thing is, what often happens is that attractive girls gain so much experience with men by the age of, say, 19 that they know every trick in the book; naive guys then expect them to be innocent and angelic at that age, and get the shock of their life when they come into closer contact with them. And then, very occasionally, you get the girl who has somehow contrived to reach the age of 22 while claiming never to have had a proper boyfriend, and you have to reset your expectations. (I consider myself a late starter, yet even I was onto my second girlfriend within a month of reaching 20.) That seems to be the case here; considering her religious views I doubt that Paula has expended all her romantic energies on ONS so you're probably right she's a virgin. Women never cease to surprise me.

So yes, she probably does need time to reflect, and she probably is a little innocent and trusting. I was starting down the "move fast" track and she most likely didn't have time to absorb what hit her!

I love your is-she-ready-to-kiss strategies: they sound fun in their own right! I think I had this down subconsciously in my younger years; after so much "time off" and with so much more to lose, I am going to have to re-learn it consciously.

mkivtt, you seem like a great guy and reading your other posts I think you must be almost exactly the same age as me; if you're interested in exchanging thoughts, partnering in this venture etc. I can PM you if you like. I do however recognize that you appear to have very different objectives from me, so totally understand if not.
 

mkivtt

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Jul 29, 2013
Messages
86
You're welcome :)

I am by no means an expert. Heck, apart from one significant, real, relationship that was perfect for the longest time but then fell apart due to her family's interference, I am a total newb except for some meaningless short-term stuff.. If only I could be 16 again and do my live over with a different set of priorities... the things I wasted my years on in hindsight. Man oh man. I'm in my late 30s too and work in the corporate world just like you do. And I have hit on younger girls at work, with success, so I am not saying I am a saint. I just took it a little slower than trying to kiss in 2 hours :)

Sometimes all we need is a second pair of eyes. I'm unsure about how to handle some situations with women, while it must be totally obvious for someone on the outside. Perhaps the same thing applied to your situation.

My goal now is just finding "the one..." I guess I'm not in this for one night stands. Strange as it sounds, my biological clock seems to be ticking, and I am tired of family / friends asking when I'm finally hitching, being the only single guy at events, seeing "dork" co-workers with hot GFs/wives, while I know I'm a better guy, and wondering what I'm doing wrong... etc. Hit me up on PM if you want anytime, no problem. And good luck with your endeavors :)
 

Marty

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Messages
1,539
Hey mkivtt:

I respect that... if you've been successful with younger girls at work, that's pretty impressive. Way to go!

One of the reasons that I became totally convinced of the correctness behind this site's philosophy is that I retrospectively applied it to some of my experiences in the past. About 2 to 3 years ago I expended a lot of effort on a 21-year-old girl (at the time), also a colleague... I actually took her on seven (!) dates, over the course of a couple months or so, without really making a decisive move. It ended only when I left that job and moved halfway round the world. I see now, with hindsight, that she really liked me and I sent her into auto-rejection: she even continues to reach out to me sometimes now. (And she is pretty experienced.) I did everything wrong: presents, fancy dinners, but most of all moving slow and showing a lack of courage. You learn!

So, that's why I'm maybe overdoing the "move fast" philosophy now. But where you are in social circle, especially in an occupational context, I think you're right it needs to be dialed back a little... without losing forward momentum or the sense of courage to press on. That's no doubt even more the case with an inexperienced girl: she might need time to accept the reality of the situation before you "lead" her to the next step, as you rightly pointed out.

Concerning your situation, I do empathize. There is a lot to be said for having someone to come home to, to go on vacation with, to take out to dinner, to take good care of. Maybe even to share secrets with, depending on your personality. I'm sure you will choose wisely: and thanks to this site, I trust you will develop a broader range of options! And don't let those family/friends advance you in the wrong direction... withstand the social pressure, they're not the ones who're going to be living with her :)

-Marty
 

Nova

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Nov 27, 2012
Messages
295
Her calling you a friend was either a test or it was genuine. The fact you are older and married may well have pushed you towards the friend territory by simply making yourself too unavailable. Whilst obviously it is important to disqualify yourself as a boyfriend candidate and thus increase your chances of her willing to sleep with you quickly, girls can look at a situation with a guy and sometimes feel as though everything is against anything intimate ever happening between you. I mean many girls need their eyes opening when it comes to the whole dating much older guys thing, society has simply closed their minds off to it. That and the fact you are married may very well have led her to believe there was no chance early on and thus pushed you into friend land. This is why its important to set the correct frames, and more importantly outframe her objections.

BUT going by what you said, she DID seem very interested in you on a deeper level going by her body language etc? So perhaps you did everything correctly with the rest of the interaction, showed her that actually you are open to the idea of something happening and she really did want you. Which if the case, I do believe she would have perhaps slept with you if you did persist past her 'your a friend test'

Its hard to know, in most cases you certainly should have persisted. Ignored her 'your a friend', asked her some more questions, invited her back to yours and the rest is history. I do understand the uncertainty though when it comes to this kinda stuff with girls from work. Messy and all that. Sometimes you wont ever know for sure if a girl will do something with you or not, despite her body language or lack of body language. Sometimes the only way to know is to ask.

One thing. Don't ask girls questions like 'Do you like talking with me', 'Do you like me', 'Am I cool' etc, its all too needy. Subtracts from your dominance and masculinity.
When it comes to 'Your a good friend tests' just ignore them and continue as though she never said it.
Don't ask a girl if she wants to kiss you, just do it when you are alone at yours, prior to sex. Never more than 10 minutes before.
 

Marty

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Messages
1,539
Thanks Nova, some really useful pointers here.

I'd have automatically made the "test" assumption if it hadn't been for how she'd made herself out to be so inexperienced... that's when I was a little thrown, I figured she didn't really know what she was doing one way or the other and might say one thing and believe another. I should've paid less attention to her words, I guess, and demonstrated greater leadership.

You make an excellent point with regard to the "Do you like me?" blunder, I regretted it the moment it came out of my mouth. I think I picked it up from some place on these boards, but I should have gone with Chase's "Things You MUST Ask Her" which I think runs like this: "What do you think of me so far?" ...much more powerful and assertive. Regrettably, I read it too late.

I am also wondering whether she had some hangups with regard to the whole spiritual thing, considering all those remarks she made along those lines... I may be off the mark here, I'm a European who's only been in the States for two to three years and I don't really yet have a handle on this whole American religious worldview (most of us buried that stuff around the time of the Enlightenment), but I gather that there are some mythological precepts concerning "covetousness" or "adultery" or whatnot which I have no idea how it gets applied in practice, if at all... I'm also in the South right now where some people really seem to dig that kind of idea. I'm too ignorant of it to make a proper judgement though, so I think I'll just let that take care of itself.

Anyway Nova, I think you're right about the possibility of being too unattainable, so now she's had a chance to absorb what took place, I'll come across as warm and easygoing as I can in order to try to outframe it like you suggest. Really appreciate your commentary... I sure need the guidance.
 
Top