What's new

Dumped her. Want to get back with her.

Nimiety

Rookie
Rookie
Joined
Sep 14, 2014
Messages
5
Alright, this feels a little bit like wading into the shark pit (especially since I know the mantra around here is "dont' chase, replace"), but I'm going to give this a go because I'm in a rebuilding phase, and am looking for as wide a range of feedback as possible.

Apologies up front for the length. I tend to be a little wordy.

So, the last two-plus years have been Hell for me, and have seen me completely fall apart because I, like a chump, long ago built my self image on external factors, and those externals disappeared. As the ground was shifting under me, and I was starting to collapse, I was dating this really great woman. She was smart, sexy, and just absolutely smoking. The sex was red hot, and she was so completely into me it actually made my head spin. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to hold myself together, and I knew it. I told her I was going through something, and that it was something that I had to do on my own.

It wasn't an easy thing to do, but I broke up with her. I did it partly because I really did need to work on myself on my own, and partly because I didn't want her to see me hit rock bottom. She was persistent, however, and told me that she'd wait for me. She asked me if I would want to get back together in the future. I told her she shouldn't wait, because I didn't know how long it would take me to deal with my problems, but that I probably would be interested in getting back together again.

She misread that as "I don't want to be with you anymore, but I want to put you down nicely", when I was being completely honest and up front. I thought I was clear, but, let's be honest here: I wasn't really in a clear head space at the the time, so that may not have been something I was at all capable of being.

We had been together for 6 months at that point. For the first two weeks after breakup, she chased me pretty hard, and tried to seduce me back. It almost worked, but she was looking for a commitment I wasn't capable of giving at the time. After the third week, she had declared that she had "moved on", and she jumped back into dating. She jumped at, I think literally, the first guy that came along after that, and they've been together since. That was about two months ago now.

Anyway, I've taken the summer to bottom out, and start rebuilding myself based on strong internal labels. Day by day my life comes together, my confidence grows, and I'm feeling stronger and stronger. I've been working on my posture, I've been working on my eye contact, and I've begun dating again. So far, it's been all low hanging fruit, as it were, but it's done some great things for my confidence as each consecutive date has been with a progressively better, more attractive woman. I'm finding myself able to hold my own in conversations, generate some genuine smiles, and make these woman laugh and have a pretty good time. More importantly, I'm able to see that I'm doing this, and feel my self-confidence grow every time. This is a huge change from just a year ago, where women seemed to find me charming, but I just didn't believe it.

So, of course, I want a second chance at my ex. She's still rebounding, but I have little doubt that this current relationship of hers will peter out. It might take a few more months, but I know the type of guy she's with, I know the type of woman she is, and I know the classic signs of a rebound when I see them. After two months of no-contact, I texted her to say hi, and to see how things were. She told me she was watching TV, and said that she hoped I was doing well. I let her know that I was doing great, and said I hoped she was as well. She totally ignored that, but we did chat very sporadically until I went to bed (I ended the conversation). When I woke up in the morning, there was one last text from her saying that she hoped I had a good night's sleep, and, again, that she hoped things had improved for me. Nothing at all about how she was. She totally avoided the topic.

When I went no-contact on her (which was a couple of days after I learned about the new guy), I was a bit of a jerk. Having re-established contact with her, I felt I should apologize for that, so I sent a short email just saying I was sorry, and briefly explained why I was being such an ass at the the time. She responded, saying that she really appreciated the apology (score!), but that it wasn't necessary, because she holds no hard feelings. She also made a point of mentioning that she had moved on, and she was happy. Personally, I don't believe she doesn't hold any hard feelings, and I'm still not convinced that she's "moved on". I do hope she's happy, though.

Anyway, I think I can read from this that she's still angry, and that this is an auto-rejection reaction. I also think she's still in the rebound phase of the break-up (she's two months out of a six month relationship that was very passionate). Since she's currently seeing someone, should I be hoping that she reaches the cool-down phase before that break-up, or should I be hoping the break-up occurs closer to the longing phase?

Either way, my plan right now is to continue dating, continue working out, continue to slim down, and continue to put on some muscle (I've been running, and I've recently joined the gym so I can use the weight machines). I'm going to give her a few weeks to digest the apology, and then text her again. Something fun and lighthearted, just to say hi, and to gauge where she is. I've recently started a new job, so that'll keep me pretty busy, and should give me the funds to refresh my wardrobe. I'm also hoping to land a second job, and once I do that I'm thinking of taking up martial arts.

I suppose the tables have sort of turned a bit, as now I'm willing to wait for her. It's just that while I'm waiting, I'm going to be living the single life, and build myself into an even more attractive catch.

So, thoughts? Is there anything I should avoid doing at this time? Is there anything specific I should be taking this time to do? Obviously, she's in a relationship, and I don't want to interfere with that, but I do want to be ready for when it ends, and while she's in this relationship, she's giving me all the time in the world to build a better me..
 

Chase

Chieftan
Staff member
tribal-elder
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
6,247
Nimiety-

I'm not sure what sort of trough you went through, but ending things with her before she had to see you at your worst can be a good call... depending on the woman and how you comport yourself when you're at your worst. I agree your communication with her made it sound like you were letting her off nicely rather than telling her you just didn't want her to be around you at your worst and would like to pick it back up again with her once you're better - the breakup sounded like you were doing it for yourself rather than for the both of you, which gave it a very different flavor, so to speak.

My feeling with this one is that it just needs more time. You broke up with her after 6 months of dating to handle something you could only do alone, and 3 months later you were all better and ready to pick it back up again with her? It just seems too fast. If it was going to be THAT fast of a recovery, it strikes me (and I surmise it would strike her) as difficult to justify breaking up over - though maybe you could, but only if you made sure she absolutely understood why you needed the break you did.

Texting 2 months after she's started seeing someone else makes you feel flip-floppy and inconsistent, like the guy who can't make up his mind. Date for 6 months, break up with her, deny her efforts to win you back for the next month, then two months later you're texting her again and want to get back together.

There might be a way you pull it off this fast, but it's going to be all her terms, and you'll have to sacrifice a lot of power in the relationship to get it. She sounds like she's angry, as you note - she's still quite bitter about your treatment, and she'd love to get her some payback and make sure that when you come back, it's on your knees. You can give her time to get over it, and by that point she may be thrilled to come running back into your arms again, but if you keep trying for now my suspicion is if it happens at all it'll happen with her wearing the pants and calling the shots.

I'm sure it's no fun to have to put it off, but if I was you I'd keep my conversation with her to something like, "Hey, I'm sorry I was a dick in how I cut things off with you. I was a mess, and I just wanted to protect you from the worst of that. Anyway, I know you've got someone now and I don't want to interfere, but if you need someone to talk to later on down the line, give me a holler." Then go hit the dating scene hard yourself and do your best to find girls like her and better than her. When she's ready to chat again, she'll let you know.

Chase
 
the right date makes getting her back home a piece of cake

Nimiety

Rookie
Rookie
Joined
Sep 14, 2014
Messages
5
Yeah, in retrospect I totally get how I sent her the wrong message. I just wasn't in a head space at the time to understand how I was coming off to someone else. I mean, "I'll be back but don't wait for me" is almost a sappy rom-com trope at this point, but I just didn't realize what I was doing. Realistically, though, I was being selfish. Realistically, I had to be selfish in order to work things through. There was definitely a better way to tell her, though.

The breakup was absolutely for me, and it was absolutely selfish. I fully believe she would have wanted to be there for me, and to help me through it, but I wasn't convinced then, and I'm even less convinced now, that she would have been able to. This really was something that I needed to do on my own. I just handled how I communicated that poorly.

I fully agree that two months of healing and rebuilding isn't enough. I'm not ready yet, and I know it. It's just that I've realized my feelings for her have survived intact, and that I now know for sure that I'd like another chance, not that I want that chance immediately. I haven't proposed getting back together to this woman, and the little contact that I have initiated could very well be summed up as

"Hey, I'm sorry I was a dick in how I cut things off with you. I was a mess, and I just wanted to protect you from the worst of that. Anyway, I know you've got someone now and I don't want to interfere, but if you need someone to talk to later on down the line, give me a holler."

I mean, it was a little more detailed than that, but that's a really good synopsis. I can't tell you how glad I am right now that I didn't play that horribly wrong. It's just that as I really start to recover, I'm able to reinterpret so much of what happened in our relationship, and while there's certainly a risk of seeing things through rose coloured glasses, the pieces fit together a lot better if I simply acknowledge that I was being prideful rather than confident, and, worse, that I was operating not only from a place of low self-confidence, but with wounded pride.

I mean, sure, I really would like another try at this. Give it a proper fresh start, once I'm capable of doing that with her. She doesn't need to know that yet, though. She deserved an apology, and I needed to get it off my chest in order to move forward, so it worked well to test the waters. I'm glad to hear that you agree that the waters are still choppy and cold, to stretch a metaphor.

I want to go about this right, so I'm in absolutely no rush. As I say, she appears to be seeing someone, and while I'm 98% certain that it's destined to fail, I don't want to be in a position to either prop it up for longer than it needs to go on (if she's really trying to rub my face in how "moved on" she is, sticking close will just keep encouraging to do so, I'm sure), nor do I want to be able to be fingered as the destabilizing agent in that relationship (I want her to be wondering "what if" about me, not this other guy).

I really enjoy your articles, Chase, so it means a lot to get a response from you that mostly validates what I'm thinking about this. I hope I've opened the door enough that she'll walk through it when she's ready. In the mean time, I'm going to keep working on my skills so that when she is ready to chat, I'll be ready to seduce her in a way she's never experienced before.
 

Nimiety

Rookie
Rookie
Joined
Sep 14, 2014
Messages
5
Just a small update, which I thought I'd post here for the sake of having a complete set of information on this.

I ran across one of my ex's friends from work this morning, and we chatted for five minutes. Typical small talk stuff. How's work going, how's your summer been, how's the family, etc. Got to show off a bit to a friend and colleague of hers that, yes, I had a rough summer, but also that things have turned around and I'm on the up-swing.

No talk of the ex until just before we parted ways, when I asked how she was doing, and if she was well. He said he thought so, but he didn't know, which was really strange. She always characterized this guy as being a brother to her, and her best friend in the city. They always hung out after work, but he said that they don't really see each other anymore. He also volunteered that she was, in fact, seeing someone new, which I still believe is the guy from 2 weeks after our breakup.

So, she's isolating herself from her friends at work (which is highly peculiar behaviour for her), and is probably spending a lot of time with her boyfriend. I'm not sure how this impacts my chances of attracting her back down the road, but this reads like typical rebound behaviour. This also sounds like yet another reason to keep my distance for a while. It's not just me that she's pulled away from, so it's not just an issue with me.

Any suggestions on how frequently I should check in on her? I'm going to lay off for at least a month, simply for my own sake, but after that how frequently should I test those waters? And given both that I was the dumper, and that she seems to be in a highly accelerated and isolating relationship, are the standard "I saw/did thing that reminded me of you/time we saw/did thing. How are things?" type text still the route to go? Or is this more of a "I wasn't ready then, but I am now, but now you're not, and oh, if only we could just get the timing right" letter of woe scenario?
 
Top