What's new

FR  Hmm not sure what went wrong here. Need some advice breaking it down.

jl90

Rookie
Rookie
Joined
Aug 24, 2014
Messages
3
Hey fellas,

My most recent date went great in my view, but she seemed dodgy about the second date when I suggested it the next day over text, and I texted her couple days after that but no reply...so I'm a bit confused about this situation since there seems to be a lot of variables. So here are the details:

I met this girl in class, and she is the one that actually pursued me, since she came and sat next to me and initiated conversation with interest. So I rewarded her investment with a little banter and deep diving about her background and such. The interaction went well and after class, I grabbed her number, and we met up the following week. I usually avoid getting involved with girls in class due to possible awkwardness if things go wrong, but she is no longer in my class so I decided to go ahead with the date.

We met up in the evening to grab a bite at a local pizza place. We grabbed the tables outside since it had a nicer atmosphere and I told her to sit closer to me instead of across from me. The conversation went great, we mostly talked about her passions, future plans, why she wants to pursue her career, etc. Some sexual topics that came up during our talks as well; since she was from Europe, she brought up some discussions about the freedom of sexuality there. We had some good eye contact the whole time with some banter and the non-verbals between us were good. After dinner, she asked if she wanted to split the bill, but I nonchalantly said I would get this one if she gets the dessert. So we leave to get some, but since it was pretty late at night by then, all the stores were closed. So, we went for a little walk and grabbed a seat on the bench. I deep dived her some more, and there were some moments of silence where we just held eye contact and there were some tension. As we were talking, some random dude came up and made us a flower out of palm leaves, so I nonchalantly gave it to her, perhaps maybe in an overly aloof way i'm not sure..(maybe a mistake). Over the course of our date, I complimented her several times in a genuine way which she seemed to appreciate. I was debating, since before the date, whether to invite her home that night. Since she went to my school and I would most likely run into her again; and I was so confused as to if I was in the lover or boyfriend candidate territory, I decided to go with the date compression route (possible big mistake here). However, since the date went well I was going to suggest a movie at my place since it was close...but a conversation came up about an old dude at a dealership that invited her home in a creepy and unprofessional manner toward the end of our date, so I felt it was inappropriate for me to do so and didn't pull the trigger. (thinking another huge mistake here). So as the conversations died down, I walked her back to her car. We hugged and after that I went in for a kiss and she did too. She grabbed my hand after and wanted me to keep in touch. I said I would and wished her good night and texted her when I got home and I had a great time as well which she replied the same.

The next evening, I shot her a text saying that last night was fun and we should get together again sometime that weekend. Here's where it went kinda downhill. She replied after a couple hours that she was extremely busy that weekend but hope and we 'see each other at school for now (?)' and get to know each other better. I figured it was a polite way of her brushing off the suggestion but I said sure and she said 'thanks for everything' (another red flag). So I replied 'maybe we'll hangout next week if i'm not too busy ;) and she said 'sure :)'. So the following week, not really expecting much, I shoot her a text suggesting to get together (in a suave manner of course) and got no reply.

Overall, it was a good learning experience moving things forward up till the date and had a good time. I didn't really care about the outcome although she's gorgeous, I didn't feel much emotions toward her. I just wanna know what I could have possibly done wrong here to improve myself for the next time. I'm thinking there were several reasons as to what could have happened:

1) Not moving fast enough and missing escalation windows, in this case inviting her home.
Should I have invited her home despite the story about the old dude making it a bit awkward for me to do so? Was date compression a wrong choice here? How do you know which route to go?
I didn't properly disqualify myself as a boyfriend so I thought I had to take this route, plus I kinda didn't want to fuck this up (but ended up doing so somehow anyway)
2) Emotional cresting/attraction expiring
I think this one is kinda given, but since she had such high level of interest in the beginning of our interaction + me not inviting her home, I'm thinking it kinda crashed soon after the date...
3)Attainability?
She is a bit taller than I am so maybe she thinks I will leave her for someone shorter than I am? (I do prefer women shorter than I am but didn't mention anything of the sort)
4)Life interfering?
Maybe her ex wanted to get back together?
5)Aloofness
I might have been slightly overly aloof toward the end..i'm not sure (it was because despite we had so much in common, I didn't really feel that much connection to her although I did really want to get together with her) and perhaps she picked up on it? Also, I didn't physically escalate much with touch, etc during the date since I was treating it more as an informational one.

I need some help breaking this interaction down...kinda confused as to what went wrong. I wish I could just call up the girl and she would give me an honest advice haha. I appreciate reading all this and your insight would help me out tremendously. Please let me know if I could have done any part of this better for future reference. Thanks!
 

NarrowJ

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Feb 13, 2013
Messages
1,275
JL,

Yeah, as you noted yourself, sometimes life just happens and things get in the way. Then the intrigue wears off a bit and some other guy steps in and asks her out on a date, and she gets excited about that and it sort of leaves you in the dust. That's why we tell guys to move fast and take women to bed quickly, because there's just so many variables and obstacles that can get in the way if things get too drawn out.

On your questions:

Should I have invited her home despite the story about the old dude making it a bit awkward for me to do so? Was date compression a wrong choice here? How do you know which route to go?

Definitely don't let stories and comments like that deter you. Are you an old dude? Are you going to ask her in a creepy way (as she suggested this other guy did)? The only reason this guy creeped her out was because he was, in fact, a fuckin' creeper. So yeah, don't worry about things like this. Your reaction here should be to just think to yourself, "That's a funny story... I bet she'll be SUPER EXCITED when I ask her to come over, because she's had to deal with weird dudes like him and now she'll finally get to have a sexy guy taking her somewhere private for some intimate fun!"

On knowing when to use date compression, the answer is that you should ALWAYS ALWAYS ALWAYS invite a girl home on a first date. Basically anytime you're unsuccessful getting sex on the first date is when you want to turn to date compression, in my opinion. If I invite the girl back to my place and she says no, I implement date compression. If the girl comes back to my place but I don't (read: can't) fuck her, I implement date compression. Just make sure you try to get sex on the first date, and if you can't then you go for date compression so things don't get stale on you like they seem to have here.


She is a bit taller than I am so maybe she thinks I will leave her for someone shorter than I am? (I do prefer women shorter than I am but didn't mention anything of the sort)

These are the types of things that you shouldn't worry yourself about. Sure, height is important to some people. But, don't assume it's important to specific people. If it was super important to her, she wouldn't have went out on a date with you.


Life interfering? Maybe her ex wanted to get back together?

Again, in your case, I think this is what likely happened. And, the reason I think this is the case is because of how well the date seemed to have went. She either got legitimately busy, or ran into some other guy (or her ex).


I wish I could just call up the girl and she would give me an honest advice haha.

Lol, yeah... that's NEVER gonna happen. Would be nice, wouldn't it?


J.J.
 
the right date makes getting her back home a piece of cake

Rtodd201

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
22
JL,

Read your post and the replies and I think NarrowJ hit on most of what I was thinking too. Read Chase's articles on Escalation Windows and Moving things fast, that should really help with seeing things from a different perspective.

IMO, you probably gave her major "serious relationship" vibes with the things you did/said and didn't do/say. Here's what I'm seeing:

Over the course of our date, I complimented her several times in a genuine way which she seemed to appreciate.

Did she do or say something that was truly worthy of multiple compliments? If she didn't and you were using compliments to keep the interaction going in a "positive" direction and showing her you like her it can really set you back. Remember you don't really "know' her yet. A stranger dumping compliments on you comes off as disingenuous and is so common I think most women start to tune out.

However, since the date went well I was going to suggest a movie at my place since it was close...but I felt it was inappropriate for me to do so and didn't pull the trigger.

This showed her you wanted to take it slow, which communicates you don't go after what you want like the European guys she's used to (most Non-Americans girls see guys from the U.S. as sensitive compared to Euros. Perfect chance for you to show her whats really up and "plant your flag" haha


So as the conversations died down, I walked her back to her car. We hugged and after that I went in for a kiss and she did too.

By waiting until she was leaving, at her car, you essentially drained all the excitement out of the kiss with her. She probably knew you were going to go for it at the end of the date instead of being charged up with the possibility that you could escalate at ANY time. Being predictable is a death sentence.

wished her good night and texted her when I got home and I had a great time as well which she replied the same.

This could look a little desperate to her. You complimented her. You gave her some flower thing. You kissed her. She knows. You don't have to tell her 30 mins after you leave, she knows. If you would have handled everything properly YOU would have got this text after the date.

The next evening, I shot her a text saying that last night was fun and we should get together again sometime that weekend. Here's where it went kinda downhill.

This is where you shoveled the final load of dirt on the grave that was your chances with this girl. She saw you as coming on too strong(I know, its hard to wrap your mind around the fact that you could try to fuck her on the first date and she wouldn't hold it against you but seem too interested AFTER your first date and it's all over but the crying), she was letting you down easy with standard "extremely busy" excuses but sent you a dagger with the "thanks for everything" line.

Just an FYI too, "sure" never means yes.

I hope this helps you JL, remember she didn't reject YOU(she doesn't really know you right?) she rejected the way you handled her.

Keep at it and you'll get it,

Rocco









Le
 

jl90

Rookie
Rookie
Joined
Aug 24, 2014
Messages
3
Great insight guys, thanks very much. I think both of you pretty much nailed everything down to science. It's nice to get a third person perspective of things, because sometimes you don't even realize what you are doing wrong even after reading many articles and putting into practice.

I actually did end up seeing her again though, i think only because luckily her initial interest level was so high.
Just letting you guys know that you guys were on point, because i found out that she came out of a long-term relationship not too long ago and was not looking for anything serious at all. Moving fast the first time would have definitely solved the case, and i guess I put out a relationship vibe without meaning to, because that's not what i really want either.

During our meetup, I actually mentioned some girl I met before at the place we were at because it sort of related to our conversation casually. I think that's what triggered her to ask me what I was looking for and I replied 'just to have fun' and she said that's what she's looking for too and brought up her situation. So long story short, I invited her home not too long after that. She was on her period though so I got head, then we sort of cuddled and took a nap together. I asked her if she would like to come over next week when she's not on her time (maybe a mistake here but i kinda wanted to know lol), but she said she wasn't sure. Just a couple questions here..would that count as a failed escalation? i mean there was nothing I could do about that one. and I would like to keep a casual relationship with her and what would be the best way to go about things? Should I shoot her a text once a week to keep her in the loop and see her once every week/ 2weeks? Thanks again!
 

Rtodd201

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
22
Damn J that is badass. Major kudos for turning this one around. If you're not looking for a relationship with her, ping her whenever you feel like it. Once a girl has done SOMETHING sexual with you, and you guys are still cool with each other, you could always pick up where you left off. Just be cool and I'm sure it'll happen eventually. Remember the next time you're dealing with her that this could have all been avoided if you had gone for it from the go. It'll help with not repeating the mistake with another girl.


Rock on!

Roc
 

fsc

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Jul 15, 2014
Messages
244
I asked her if she would like to come over next week when she's not on her time
It might have went better if you were a little more dominant, such as "What are you doing next week? You should come see me again when mother nature is done with you," rather than asking.

Definitely hit her up again soon and schedule something, preferably when she's done with her period. Meet up for something light like coffee or frozen yogurt, chat her up a little, then bring up the idea of a casual relationship. Good luck
 
Top