What's new

How to Respond "How Many Girls Have You Been With"?

Sandman

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Apr 18, 2016
Messages
356
Sometimes (well most of the times) girls ask you how many girls have you been with after you sleep with them. If the girl is inexperienced, the actual number might scare her away or if your number is lower it looks bad on you.

I usually just playfully evade the question "Why do you wanna know?" "What do you think it is" etc. But I would like to know if there is a better way to answer this question. Maybe it's situational i.e. (i) if you number is higher, (ii) if it's similar, (iii) if it's lower.

What do you guys think?
 

Chase

Chieftan
Staff member
tribal-elder
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
6,456
mrre-

mrre said:
Sometimes (well most of the times) girls ask you how many girls have you been with after you sleep with them. If the girl is inexperienced, the actual number might scare her away or if your number is lower it looks bad on you.

I usually just playfully evade the question "Why do you wanna know?" "What do you think it is" etc. But I would like to know if there is a better way to answer this question. Maybe it's situational i.e. (i) if you number is higher, (ii) if it's similar, (iii) if it's lower.

What do you guys think?

Girl: How many girls have you been with?
mrre: What do you think? Take a guess.
Girl: I don't know... 10.
mrre: Close! It's 9.

...

Girl: How many girls have you been with?
mrre: What do you think? Take a guess.
Girl: 25!
mrre: Pretty good.
Girl: So I'm right.
mrre: You're very close. I'm 26.

...

Girl: How many girls have you been with?
mrre: What do you think? Take a guess.
Girl: 3.
mrre: Very close.
Girl: What is it?
mrre: I'm at 5.

---

Girls will tell you what they think you are. Whatever it is, it's usually a safe bet if they already like you.

The only time it is not a safe bet is if they are in auto-rejection and ask you this. In that case, take whatever number they say and cut it in half (or quarters, if the auto-rejection is especially bad).

If you don't want to fib, then tell her you hate the idea of numbers and have made a conscious effort to spend zero time reliving the past or recording the past. So your number is not CRAZY high or anything, but because you've actively disallowed yourself from counting lovers you aren't sure what it is. Nor do you care to know, nor want to.

You can also just tell them the number, consequences be damned.

But there are consequences. If your number is high, she will never trust you for monogamy and you will hear about it forever (years and years later).

Chase
 

alleniverson

Modern Human
Modern Human
Joined
May 27, 2013
Messages
110
In the past I have replied by saying "I'm a virgin" which las led to laughs and flirting ("shut uppppp" *playful slap*) and if they press I've just stuck with it and they normally let the question go. I think that is a good look , assuming the girl doesn't think there's a chance you're actually a virgin.

EDIT:: this is for before you hit it
 

Big Daddy

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Jan 26, 2013
Messages
707
Chase, is it safe to reflect the question after you give an answer?

I don't care for the most part and have never asked a girl how many guys she's been with, but this context provides an easy hook to satisfy my curiosity without being super lame.
 
you miss 100% of the shots you don't take
Top