What's new

in over my head right off the bat...with online dating

carpedm

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Aug 21, 2013
Messages
26
Hey guys, this is my second post. I look forward to your insight on the coming topic. If you like, check out my brief self-introduction in my first post, found over in Field Reports>Journals.

The situation is thus: Here I am on GC, and I need you to help me remedy a shaky situation I've put myself into on my dating website. To cut to the chase, so to speak, I'm garnering a lot of interest on there, but only since I (wait for it...) put up the main picture of myself as one from about 3 years ago when I also happened to be about 30 lbs. lighter. Now, I know what you're thinking, but you're going to have to take my word on this--I did not post this picture to intentionally trick girls into thinking I look totally different than I actually do. Further in my defense, there is also another photo on my profile of me from about 2 weeks ago. The third and final photo is a zoomed out shot of me playing guitar, but that's a superfluous detail.

The reason I posted this picture as my main picture in the first place is because (taking the advice from the Plenty of Fish article by Ricardus [I think] and from Chase's forum post about online dating 101) it is the only picture of myself where I am looking down, and away from the camera. Well, what do you know--it absolutely worked just like the OKCupid! study claimed it would. But the predicament is that I now have a lot of messages going with various women who, more often than not, reached out to me first and are thinking I look like my main profile picture when I look considerably different.

So I need advice on how to proceed. In my opinion, meeting these girls in person and having them potentially be disappointed/feeling mislead about my true appearance would be, at best, embarrassing and awkward, and worse yet potentially damaging to my reputation. Maybe I'm being paranoid, but it may even be deemed a deceitful enough move on my part that it gets these girls to (somehow, though I don't know exactly how) go out and message other girls and warn them about me or something.

What should I do?
 

Estate

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Dec 20, 2012
Messages
798
Honestly... it's not as big a deal as you are feeling right now.

Don't worry about your "reputation"... online dating is like it's own little social media social circle, it won't effect your real life if one girl likes you and one doesn't.

Next... Girls do this ALL THE TIME. When I did online dating I was stung by this a few times and also girls are good at picturing themselves from the "right angle" to appear more attractive or slim than they are. It's not exactly a new thing so don't worry about that.

Honestly though... I've met up with girls in the past who I literally did not recognize. I looked all around, couldn't see anyone like the pictures I saw and finally the girl would approach me and I'd be stunned. Some of them were actually quite nice girls but it wasn't a turn-on from the get go to feel a little cheated.

So your options are kinda obvious:
1. You could just change the picture. Do you really look a LOT different?
2. Be honest about it... I've seen some people put a caption on pics saying "This was last week" or "This was 2 years ago but its a nice picture".
3. If you're already talking to them, again, be honest, it was taken 2 years ago, it was your best picture and you might look a little different now... then it's up to her... she might not like it but there you go.. her choice, what can you do.
4. Just don't say/do anything... if you meet them, they might love you anyway or they might not. It's just the risk you take...

Of couse there is Option 5... shut down your profile and go offline... much better girls out in the real world ;)
 
you miss 100% of the shots you don't take

carpedm

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Aug 21, 2013
Messages
26
Thank you for chiming in, Estate.

I am first going to add a caption to my main photo, then when I get a better one that is taken more recently, I'll get rid of the old photo completely. Additionall, as I don't look drastically different now than my main profile picture, plus with the fact that I have included another photo from about two weeks ago, I am most likely going to follow up with the current girls who I want to see. One actually just recently asked me to grab drinks soon, so I'll start there. In the meantime, I'm getting back into running and eating right after a hiatus due to a cold, so I should drop some weight pretty quickly anyways.

I very much look forward to starting my newbie assignment (Thursday is my start date due to my current schedule), and with that I couldn't agree more that meeting women in person will be much, much more effective than online dating. There are a multitude of reasons for this, and I'm sure you've come to your own conclusions--in fact, I saw your recent thread on exactly the subject of you recently quitting online dating. It avoids the issue of girls who deceive with their profile pictures, and probably more importantly it immediately breaks the ice, whereas with online dating you always have that anxious period where you are meeting for the first time in person and crossing your fingers that you can actually recognize the girl in person or that she can recognize you, so you sit there looking around for her. But I digress...

Thanks again. I consider this thread resolved.
 
Top