What's new

In Person Coaching? Is it Worth it? if so which one?

Jeet02

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Nov 20, 2012
Messages
112
Hey fellas,

Few years ago when I started reading Girls Chase and other dating-esque advices out there, I hit a break through. I improved my game a lot and just became a better man overall. However, as of late I have hit a little bit of a dry spell. I moved to NYC back in the summer and havent met that many women at all. Mostly because I am really busy at work, but also because I don't know where to go or what to do to meet women. Tinder and all those apps just suck. The only girls I know are from work...and although some of them are interesting, most are in a relationship or just don't cut it.

Which brings to in person coaching. It has made me think that perhaps with some live coaching from some good "pua"s in NYC will help me. I feel like my current problem is basically approaching women in order to meet them. It is hard for me to do at bars...but maybe i need to start doing it.

My question is then - has anyone done any of these live/in person coaching? Have they worked..at all? If so, which ones?

Any help...suggestions...thoughts...would be greatly appreciated.

Cheers,
Jeet
 

ray_zorse

Modern Human
Modern Human
Joined
Aug 12, 2014
Messages
1,982
Mate I have not done any in-person coaching and have found it possible to level up using just the advice on GC and the forums.

Probably the biggest problem here is approach anxiety... it's really hard to go out by yourself and get stuck in your head and still force yourself to approach. Whereas if you go out with a buddy you're automatically socializing at a baseline level (cos you're not stuck in your head, you're talking to your buddy) and there's also a nice team spirit, like he says "go approach that woman" and you feel totally intimidated but you do it anyway, cos you can't look like a pussy and let the team down. IMO this is one of the main things guys get out of bootcamps, they've never approached before and they put themselves in a position where there is a social pressure to approach (and then obviously they find it's not that difficult so it breaks the ice).

Since you're in NYC I'd basically guarantee there's some dudes here on the boards who would be willing to meet up with you, if you were in Melbourne, Australia I'd certainly be happy to. But you may as well work on your fundamentals and conversation a bit by yourself, cos that takes time.

Some other problems with in-person coaching and bootcamps are that (1) that they're very costly and (2) you're gonna be exposed to a particular kind of material which might not work for you. I dunno about you, but I find the material on GC resonates with me because it's basically about "natural game" and becoming the best man you can possibly be -- no tricks are taught here (well not many), but it does take a long time to level up. So a single "bootcamp" is not really gonna have a huge impact, it's really about the cumulative effect of the effort you put in over a long period. What you're aiming to do is make things like sexual flirting a "part of who you are"... this is something a bootcamp cannot teach.

-Ray
 

Jeet02

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Nov 20, 2012
Messages
112
Agreed. GC has so many amazing articules and I have learned a lot. Like you said, one of the reasons I like it is because it is natural. It is social skills not "how to fool girls to like you". Which is why I respect Chase a lot. I have definitely applied some of his lessons in real life and they have helped me a ton.

But...right now I am in that "stuck" phase I guess. Where I feel like I need something else to push me over my comfort zone and improve my game to where it needs to be. Maybe it is like you said, maybe I should meet with a few people that are in the city and help each other out. I will definitely consider it...

I was looking specifically into "the social man" 's fearless bootcamp...but I don't know how much that would be. It will probably be costly...so we will see.

Thanks for responding and the encouraging words.

Cheers,
Jeet
 

Mr.Rob

Modern Human
Modern Human
Joined
Jun 16, 2013
Messages
1,897
Actually I'm thinking about taking a bootcamp right now.

I've never been to one but I think if you do your research and find a coach that's too your style and you agree with their values and whatnot I'm sure there's a lot to be learned.

The reason I'm looking into taking a bootcamp is to have an expert point out the places where I'm going wrong that I'm not typically realizing. I know there's quite a few blindspots I have that slowly reveal themselves too me but I feel a veteran (like Chase) could point out instantly and then have a plan for where to proceed.

It's like if you want to get really good at playing guitar you go take lessons from the master, or whomever you aspire to become like. It's paying for a mentor.

I really want to get this stuff figured out. I love seduction and I love pimping.

I know in my past chosen discipline of surfing if I would've put my pride aside and hired a coach to come surf with me point out my exact sticking points and work with them with me I would've been able to excel much faster than I did.

However without it your left to ponder where you're fucking up on your own and treating symptoms as opposed to problems.

In your case it may not be a bad idea to get hire a guy to push you into sets and help destroy your AA. However if that's all you want to do and you don't want to go to a hugely high level I'd save your money, meet a more experienced wing on a puaforum or something and go out with him and pay him a smaller fee (or equivalent value "drinks for the night" "dinner at X restaurant"). Have a positive fun attitude (don't be a drag to be around), be willing to learn and take feedback, and you might just end up making a good friend or at least help get over your AA.

I met a guy recently on an online forum, he'ss a newbie and I've been pushing him into sets and showing him the beginner foundation type of stuff I know works just because I wanted a guy to go out with.

Make your decision based off your goals but if you just need help overcoming AA I would try alternate solutions prior to dropping 2 G's for a bootcamp.

-Rob
 

Jeet02

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Nov 20, 2012
Messages
112
Rob - you sound like you have some experience under your belt already. What would you say are your main goals for the bootcamp?

To me it might be AA, as the main goal, but I am sure there are still soooo many things I can do better. There are still girls I am not able to get out on dates even if I get their numbers and what not. So definitely a lot to learn.

2 G's?! IS that how much these bootcamps usually go for...?
 

Drck

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Feb 14, 2013
Messages
1,488
What do you guys expect from boot camp at first place? The material on GC covers pretty much everything. It takes time to go over it and practice it. Boot camps could be good, but IMO you won't learn anything that you already don't know. You will just see some guy telling you what you already know or doing what you know you should be doing. Like said above, there are no tricks...
 

Mr.Rob

Modern Human
Modern Human
Joined
Jun 16, 2013
Messages
1,897
@ Jeet- My main goal with taking a bootcamp is to pinpoint exactly where and how I need to improve and get real time experience with someone who's better than me. Instead of finding a mentor I'm going to buy one.

Drck said:
IMO you won't learn anything that you already don't know.
Perhaps you're right and I'm just brainwashed from marketing exposure (honestly) but as aforementioned, theoretically in my mind it would be the same as a singer hiring a voice coach, an amateur weightlifter hiring a personal trainer, or a meditation practitioner going to meet the Buddha or some shit.

It's just a way to speed up the learning curve, cancel out the dumb unconscious mistakes we all make but don't realize, and get a game plan for what exactly the next stage looks like.

I think I remember Chase mentioning he took a bootcamp around 2 years in and gained value out of it. That was years ago I'm sure now if you find that right one they'd be quite a bit better as far as coaching goes.

I've always made slow but steady progress since I started going 3 steps forward and 1 step back. My hope with taking a boot camp would be to get a professionals perspective to shoot me to the next level.

Curious to yall's opinions though!

-Rob
 

ray_zorse

Modern Human
Modern Human
Joined
Aug 12, 2014
Messages
1,982
Dude if u decide u want to teach the bootcamp i'm in.....hehehe seriously though I recently took the quiz, didnt get much out of it the first time but now i've hit more of a technician level i found the associated pdf to be packed with useful suggestions, articles to read & homework, when i have a bit more free time i plan to follow it seriously...maybe try that?
-Ray
 

Drck

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Feb 14, 2013
Messages
1,488
Ok, I'm not saying bootcamp is bad, it might be quite helpful. How does it work exactly anyway?

1. One student or bunch of students get together and some experienced guy is teaching them. Ok, there are diferent styles and different personalities, and there is lots of material so learning new things and reviewing old ones is always good. No problem.

2. But how is it with practice? The guru gets to some public areas, and what? He approaches some girl, he talks to her - while others are observing and listening..??? Ok, and then he ideally gets her number. It must actually be quite fun to watch the guru getting rejected by several girls in a row and keep rolling forward as if nothing happened, LOL. Ok, but all of that is still good.

But what is next? Does the guru take his student(s) with when he goes for a first date with the new girl? Second date? Even if it is one-on-one this might be quite problematic, especially when it goes as far as taking the girl home and becoming intimate. The guru may, of course, record the whole thing on some hidden camera, but that smells with legal problems.

I mean, would you want girl secretely taping you while you are on date with her, going home with her and getting intimate - and then find yourself on youtube under title "How to nail a silly and cute dude on a first date" with hundreds of comments below?

Maybe there are some other ways, but I just don't see any...
 

Jeet02

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Nov 20, 2012
Messages
112
I think it comes down to what Rob was mentioning. It is to bypass some of the silly mistakes and just fix exactly what needs fixing. Beyond that, in bootcamp they will push you beyond anything else. They will make you do things you wouldn't do before, to get you out of your comfort zone and break you free. At least thats what I would hope to get out of it, at least that's what I think I need.

It is the same thing with going to the gym. You might have been going for years, but suddenly you start training with an actual trainer and your results just explode. You learn the actual technique and the "science" behind it and suddenly, even when you are working by yourself, you are getting far better results. That's kinda how I see it...that's kinda how I hope it is...

-Jeet
 

Mr.Rob

Modern Human
Modern Human
Joined
Jun 16, 2013
Messages
1,897
Drck said:
It must actually be quite fun to watch the guru getting rejected by several girls in a row
haha

Btw Drck I'm taking the phone call boot camp exclusive for guys that are chodes on the phone.

For a mere 2,000 you get to watch your favorite PUA guru make live infield phone calls for 8 hrs. straight.

;)

In all seriousness I think a bootcamp (with a small student to instructor ratio) is basically hiring the "guru", as you say, to be your personal wingman and you wing each other. I believe he then points out where your being a bitch, what you need to tighten up, and what your doing good. Lastly I think they talk through the stage of development your in and when they were there and what they did to get to the next level.

But I'm merely speculating.

Has anyone out there actually taken a bootcamp? Relate your experience!
 

Chase

Chieftan
Staff member
tribal-elder
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
6,358
Drck said:
IMO you won't learn anything that you already don't know.

Same thought I took with me into every pickup or business course I signed up for over the years (but I signed up anyway).

Always left with lessons that shaved 1 to 4 years off my learning curve in one or more areas.

I think the most important element to making the lessons from in-person training stick is that you MUST get to work zealously applying what you learned as soon as the training is over, and spend at least a few weeks doing this.

The guys who advance extremely rapidly after their coaching sessions all do this. The guys who continue to just float and drift along do not.

It's always a bit tragic, because you saw these guys get results far outside their norms during the training, oftentimes doing stuff that they already knew they SHOULD do, but simply didn't do regularly, for whatever reason... their form is a bit off, they're gun-shy on certain things... and you get them doing it, and they are absolutely flying. And then the coaching ends, and you chat with them a week or two later and they still haven't gone out and attempted a solo repeat of what you covered in the coaching. "I will! I'm going out soon!" they tell you.

Here's my unofficial criteria for signing up for any kind of training, mentorship, or the like:

  • Have you read reviews, studied this guy's method, or otherwise been convinced he knows his stuff inside and out?
  • Does this guy have the right mix of demonstration (shows you what it looks like) and instruction (zeroes in on your issues, gives you specific, tailored tips, and gets you in action)? The guy who's all demonstration will 'wow' you but you won't learn much because you'll do little else but observe, while the guy who's all instruction may have good advice but you can leave wondering if he actually walks the walk, and questioning his suggestions
  • Are you definitely, ABSOLUTELY going to go and apply every lesson like clockwork until it's completely internalized after?

If you can answer "YES" to all three questions, honestly and completely, you need to sign up ASAP, because the sooner you're leveling up your skills the sooner you're where you want to be and the more success you can enjoy / the more time you can have to devote on other things.

If you answer "NO" to any question, then either you need more information, you need to find someone else to train with, or the timing simply isn't right.

Re: the "personal wingman" remark, if an instructor is serving as this, he's a bad instructor, and just using you to help him get laid (you'd be amazed how consistently you'll get laid as an instructor on bootcamps; women rapidly recognize that there are other men looking to you as this charismatic leader figure... you also behave a lot more boldly and energetically when you're putting on a performance like this). A good instructor will do a few demonstrations if you need to get juiced up / ready for the night, but otherwise the rest of his time will be spent observing you, critiquing you, and telling you what he's going to have you do next to progress further in your very next interaction.

I'd also ask for an "end of the night review" where the instructor sums up what he sees as your strengths to enhance, and your weaknesses to resolve. Probably tell him you want this before the outing commences so he's taking mental nights as the night progresses, rather than doing everything on autopilot and then he doesn't remember later what he observed when you ask him.

@ Jeet-

As for the Social Man... I don't know anything about their bootcamps personally. Not even sure whom they've got teaching. However, they're probably one of the closest training companies out there to what we teach at GC; Christian had a J.V. going on for a while with one of my mentors, and he coached up a good friend of mine and introduced him to the world of pickup back when both were living in Ann Arbor. I got to spend a little time with him in L.A. last autumn after having corresponded with him off and on for years and he's a really cool, really down-to-Earth dude who's super focused on just providing as much value as he possibly can.

So, I'd check them out, check out what they're teaching, see what the reviews on their instructors are, but if they're anything like Christian himself, you'll almost certainly learn a lot.

Whether you go out and apply it after and mold those lessons and the energy you get from the bootcamp into hardened, cemented lessons and momentum after, or you let it all fade away into memory as some kinda-sorta cool weekend you had once that didn't result in any lasting gains, will be up to what you do with what you experience in the 2 or 3 weeks after you experience it.

Chase
 

Jeet02

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Nov 20, 2012
Messages
112
Chase,

As always thanks a lot for your input and detailed post. Definitely helped me out a lot. I signed up for their initial "contact" box and they are supposed to call me but havent heard anything yet. I am waiting to talk to them to see what they offer exactly and how much it would be...but they look like they are similar to your kind of teaching. I feel like it is definitely what I need to break that barrier that is currently holding me back.

Also - did you ever go to Good Time Charley's in Ann Arbor? I have heard stories about that place haha

Thanks again man! I will keep everyone updated if I go through with it.

-Jeet
 
a good date brings a smile to your lips... and hers
Top