Wouldn't it be easier to type "me" for your quotes instead of "PeacockMan". It makes me wonder if you're super proud of your username.
The reason I type "PeacockMan" in 3rd person when writing my conversations is I think it flows better and would look much nicer to the reader (yourself and others on here).
Same reason I add the names of the ladies (fake names of course) to give the conversation context and make it easier to read. Here are 3 ways I could write my reports:
Example 1
Me: Hi ladies. How are you?
Girl #1: I am fine (smiling)
Girl #2: Hey PeacockMan (gives me a hug)
Example 2
Me: Hi ladies. How are you?
Myesha: I am fine (smiling)
Candice: Hey PeacockMan (gives a hug)
Example 3
PeacockMan: Hi ladies. How are you?
Myesha: I am fine (smiling)
Candice: Hey PeacockMan (gives a hug)
............from these 3 examples of how it could go, my opinion is I rank example 1 as the weakest from a readibility and user experience standpoint. Example # 2 is a little better but I don't like the whole "me" thing when I'm already including the girls names (or guy name) when writing my conversations. So I chose to go with Example 3 as it is comprehensive and will be easy on the eyes to read and comprehend quickly who is speaking and what is being said.
Hope this clarifies!
PeacockMan