What's new

RR: My first breakup(My longest post thus far)

Bboy100

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jan 2, 2015
Messages
1,107
Disclaimer: This post is only written so I can put what I feel on paper. I don't actually expect anyone to read this entire manifesto.


I feel like I'm dying. I just ate for the first time in two days cause I didn't have an appetite. I've only slept two hours in the past 2 days. I've spontaneously burst into tears more times than I can count. And the pain...the throbbing pain in my chest. It feels like death itself. I've had two therapy sessions in two days.

Here's the story...

Six months ago, I met a girl on my birthday. She was a virgin at the time. It was clear to me from the start that she had self-esteem issues, some anxiety problems and worries excessively. But it seemed like kind of a small thing. I wasn't sure how deep this rabbit hole would go till about a month ago...

She left to go visit her family in Portugal for the summer. The day after she left, she sent me a text saying she has HPV, and since I'm the only guy she's had sex with, it means I must have given it to her. She then cut contact with me for two full days. To be honest, I didn't think she was concerned about the HPV itself. I thought she was mad because we allowed this to happen when she had specifically mentioned at the start that she doesn't have the vaccination for it. And also, I worry that she may have realized she's not ok with the kind of relationship we have (it was an open relationship). And this is almost the physical manifestation of this dissatisfaction.

Turns out, her concern legit was the HPV virus. She thought it was a serious disease. She had a lot of misinformation on what it is. I knew very little about it. So when she told me all the horrible things she had read online, I panicked a little too. So I went to a doctor to get more information that day. As I explained the problem to the doc with a distressed look on my face, he almost chuckled at me. He explained to me that hpv is no big deal and he told me what it really does etc etc. I was instantly relieved.

I explained all this to her. She felt a little better, but she was still worried about the small chance that she might develop genital herpes. She also feels dirty, like "no guy will want her anymore". Moreover, she's absolutely terrified at the idea of telling someone new that she has hpv.

After she got the diagnosis, everything changed. I would consider that to be the end of the relationship we had before. Everything after this was just grasping at straws. We used to smile, laugh, have long, fun, interesting, intimate conversations together. And when she's around we also had great sex. Anytime I sent her a snapchat or text, she would always reply relatively quickly, and she would try. They were enjoyable. After she got diagnosed, all of this stopped. She very selectively replied to my texts, she never replied to my snaps, and even when she did, she wouldn't really try. She would always give one word answers/replies to everything I say.

Anyways...after we went to the doctor, I called her on Skype to try to hash things out with her. She explained to me that she's mad at me, and she's mad at herself for allowing this to happen. Despite the fact that we hadn't actually done anything wrong, we had now way of knowing about the hpv etc etc., she was still mad. In fact, she didn't even blame me. She's just upset at me (and herself). In the middle of the call, she had a meltdown. She started crying frantically, screaming "I'm not crazy ok? I just feel really awful right now!"

It was then and there that I realized two things:
1. She may not be as good a relationship candidate as I had previously assessed her to be. Because it seems her "minor" anxiety/worrying issues were not minor at all. They were enough to make her completely miserable after one relatively small hiccup. Unless she deals with said anxiety/worrying, what is happening now is doomed to be repeated over and over again within the relationship until it dies.
2. We're in a much bigger mess than I originally thought.

Eventually, we ended the call because it was "getting to be too much for her" (she was already in tears as she said this). In the following days, I tried texting her a few times, she didn't reply. I started to panic and get a little needy. I think I texted her to Skype me 3 times in one day or something like that? At the end, she finally replied and said yes.

When we got on Skype, she was literally starring daggers at me. Like, she legit looked like she hated my guts. First, I addressed the whole "why are you not texting me back" issue. She said she's just been super busy cause she's traveling etc. Given that I texted her three times within the same day, I'm not really in a position to call her out on this, because regardless of her reasons, I look needy. So I just apologized for misunderstanding the situation. Also, at the time, I kind of believed her. In hindsight, I think she wasn't just busy. She was also avoiding me because she associates me with the unpleasant feelings she has rn (more on that in a bit!). The rest of the call went really well. I got her to smile/laugh for the first time in a long time. By the end of it, she seemed to be at least ok with talking to me. Certainly, she wasn't angry.

Also, after that Skype, I quit texting her because I sincerely believed she was super busy all the time. Two days later, she texts me "hi". I text her back "Hi :)" . She responds, "Are you mad at me?" I tell her I'm not and ask her why she thinks I am. She says its cause I haven't initiated any conversations with her recently. I told her its because last time we talked, it sounded like she's super busy. So I decided to just wait till she has free time and gets back to me. Also, I just didn't want to come off as needy (I told her this too).

Over the course of the next few days, we have a few more text conversations. Still very dull and bland because she quit trying a while ago. But at least we're communicating now, so I was happy with that.

Then one day, I text her asking her if she's down to Skype. She doesn't reply for almost 24 hours. I get legit angry for the first time. I send her the following text:

"So, you tell me you want me to initiate more conversations. So I try to get you to Skype with me. And you can't even give me the dignity of a response for over 24 hours? That's disrespectful"

She almost instantaneously responded. She said she's been really busy traveling Spain, and she has something she needs to tell me, but she doesn't necessarily know how. She tells me she went to a doctor cause she finally can't take it anymore (remember, the entire problem is that she's worried about hpv lol). And also, apparently she had a wart. So she actually was developing genital warts. I ask her if she got treatment. She said she did. I ask her if they'll have any consequences. Her reply was "emotional damage". She says she literally hates herself now, and she can't sleep at night. She says she thinks no guy will ever want to sleep with her again and that she'll never be able to have sex. I reassure her that I would still sleep with her. She asked me if I would actually *want* to. I said yes, ofc. She said she'll talk to me tomorrow (over Skype)

The next day, we get on Skype. This was the worst one of all. The look on her face....pure disgust. Like I killed her child or something. Her voice...filled with hatred and disdain. This conversation only lasted 15 minutes. The rest lasted hours. Basically, the gist of it was this: She apparently "talked to someone and she refuses to disclose who" and now she feels a lot better about the hpv thing. She understands that its nbd and she'll be fine.

But she says she doesn't want to talk to me anymore until we get back to school in the Fall. She wants to heal and also enjoy her trip, and by talking to me, she can't do that because she associates me as the face all that's happened. In other words, her mind has associated me with all the negative emotions, all the pain of the last month, all the misery. At this point, I'm completely crushed. I feel weak and panicky. I ask her in a very weak voice....then what? Do you want to hang out in the Fall? Her answer was "I don't know." And that's the end. That happened yesterday.

For those of you who don't know, if a girl puts the breaks on a relationship, then says that she "doesn't know" if we'll get back together, that's either her polite way of rejecting me. Or, she really means it (that she doesn't know). But at the end, the relationship still won't survive.

I made a lot of mistakes:
1. Before all of this started, I was the one in charge of the relationship. I was the dominant one. But as soon as this happened, I started trying waay too hard to take care of her feelings and to make things easy as possible for her. As a result, she slowly but surely started to supercede me and take the reins. As you guys may have seen by that last call, she was calling all the shots. This was a complete 360 from before.
2. I tried to fix her problems for her. Clearly, she has an anxiety issue which needs serious treatment. And she needs to want to fix it. She doesn't want to fix it. There's nothing I can do about that. I didn't realize that, so all my efforts just backfired on me.
3. I tried to comfort her in a "logical" way. I didn't really relate with her emotionally. She was always freaking out and panicked. I was always calm and collected. I thought this would be a good approach because if we're both panicked, it'll seem hopeless. Whereas if there's at least one person who's being a rock, he can inspire confidence in the other. This had the exact opposite effect. It made me seem unrelatable. In that last call, she told me she thought I didn't take her problems seriously cause I was so casual about it. Like it was no big deal. She felt like I was brushing this off when I shouldn't be. Truthfully, I was just keeping my emotions in check. However, in the last Skype call (which is when she brought this up), I did reveal my true emotions to her. I showed her that I was terrified. I told her I can't sleep at night. I told her I'm not 100% sure what I would tell a new girl I sleep with that I have hpv. I told her that my social anxiety is through the roof because of all this. She thanked me for this.

Parting Thoughts:
-This was a great relationship. Despite the rough ending, I would consider it a success. Because the 6 months prior to this, it was an absolute bliss. And I've learned so much from it.
- Even if she does come back to me, I'm not sure how I would continue to have a relationship with her. As long as she retains these anxiety problems, she will always be undatable. Because sooner or later, something will happen and her anxiety will get the best of her. Then we'll be traveling down this dark path again.
- I'm writing this post to cope with the unbearable pain I feel right now.
- It really eates me up not knowing who this mystery person who she "talked to" is. Ik he's not a guy she fucked cause I straight up asked her, and she got genuinely furious at the notion of it. Regardless of who he is, he managed to do in one one conversation what I failed to do for a whole month. Also, I strongly suspect that he's partially responsible for her decision to cut me off. And why doesn't she want to tell me who he is anyways?

If you actually read this entire post. Thank you. I appreciate you.
 

WayOfHand

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Dec 12, 2015
Messages
98
Hello BBoy, I'm happy you are viewing your past relationship in such a constructive light. Also thank you for sharing your experience with this kind of girl.

I'm dealing with similiar sounding case with a girl that has serious anxiety issues and I'm the second guy for her. In my case, I'm the one starting to wonder if the anxiety issues are really worth the trouble. She is high sex drive and chases super hard which sort of pushes me slightly off also (the passion trap that Ricardus wrote a time back). Also she gets panic attacks sometimes. Otherwise lovely and striving young lady!

I would be interested to hear if anyone else has similiar experiences and what ended up happening. More precisely, how to view flaws in girls. There is no such thing as perfect, in every aspect, but how much should you really tolerate.
 

Drck

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Feb 14, 2013
Messages
1,488
I feel you man, rejections are tough... They are always personal, no matter what people say, and they fucking hurt... I've dealt with rejection several times, I'm still learning by my own mistakes as well as mistakes of others... So if you don't mind I'm going to make some comments...

Some high yields:
* If there is any good thing on rejection, it is that you know that are able to connect with other person on deep level...
* As you get rejected several times, the pain is usually lesser and lesser...
* The more you get rejected the more you realize need for Abundance Mentality, even if it is just keeping 1-2 girls within reach on the side...
* If you are not ready for rejection (even if the relationship feels currently perfect) you may suffer very long time. I'm talking months, even years...
* Monitor for Red Flags, there are usually plenty before you get the "hit"...

------------------------------

she sent me a text saying she has HPV, and since I'm the only guy she's had sex with, it means I must have given it to her. She then cut contact with me for two full days. To be honest, I didn't think she was concerned about the HPV itself.
>>>> The thing is, if a girl is having some hesitancy about you, she will find ANY reason to break up with you or to push you away. As far as I can say, any health reasons are not uncommon at all. Think about it, if she really loved you (and women love men differently than men love women) she would easily overcome this minor health issue... Girl starts talking about lots of medical issues, it is a Red Flag...

ADDED: Also beware of Sh*t test... Everything goes well, she loves you, and "suddenly" somethings goes wrong... She goes cold, doesn't respond, doesn't text back... What does Beta guy do? He freaks out, starts bombarding her with calls and texts... In the mean time, she is observing his reactions, wishing that he doesn't overreact... But wrong, Beta male overreacts - if he was pretending to be Alpha, she knows right away he is a fake... She feels betrayed.... True Alpha would not react, he would keep calm and cool for days... She will know right away he is not a fake - she will come back to him very happy... That's why many guys who pretend to be Alpha screw up, the end result is usually worse than if they present themselves as regular Betas... Beta wouldn't be Sh*t tested this way because she already knows he would over-react... She tests only guys who appears like Alpha but have some incongruences as she wants to find out is True Nature, whereas Beta Boy usually gets a slack...

And also, I worry that she may have realized she's not ok with the kind of relationship we have (it was an open relationship). And this is almost the physical manifestation of this dissatisfaction.
>>>> Correct

Turns out, her concern legit was the HPV virus. She thought it was a serious disease. She had a lot of misinformation on what it is.
>>>> Depending on what is she looking for, woman can magnify anything. Or minimize for that matter of fact... If she is magnifying things (such as health issues) it could be for two reasons. She may show you honesty while thinking long term. Or, she may trying to hint that she is "unhealthy" in some way, meaning she wants you to leave her alone...

I explained all this to her. She felt a little better, but she was still worried about the small chance that she might develop genital herpes. She also feels dirty, like "no guy will want her anymore".
>>>> See? She is THINKING and TALKING about OTHER GUY. Not about you. Red Flag... She may already have somebody on the side... Remember, whether you failed the test or whether she was already thinking about break up (or both), now she knows that you are not Alpha because you showed her your cards clearly... She now knows you have a needy behavior and some insecurities...

After she got the diagnosis, everything changed.
>>>> IMO it was before the diagnosis, the diagnosis is only an escape from current relationship... Watch for Red Flags...

She very selectively replied to my texts, she never replied to my snaps, and even when she did, she wouldn't really try. She would always give one word answers/replies to everything I say.
>>>> She is building a wall between you and her. Big, tall and cold wall... She is replying less and less, she is colder and colder, she is moving away (from you)... Red Flag...

Anyways...after we went to the doctor, I called her on Skype to try to hash things out with her. She explained to me that she's mad at me, and she's mad at herself for allowing this to happen. Despite the fact that we hadn't actually done anything wrong, we had now way of knowing about the hpv etc etc., she was still mad. In fact, she didn't even blame me. She's just upset at me (and herself). In the middle of the call, she had a meltdown. She started crying frantically, screaming "I'm not crazy ok? I just feel really awful right now!"
>>>> She is justifying her behavior. She needs some reason in her mind to break up... She is getting too emotional, creating too much of a drama... perhaps signaling you to walk away from her as she is mentally "unhealthy"?? Watch for Red Flag...


Eventually, we ended the call because it was "getting to be too much for her" (she was already in tears as she said this).
>>>> She is playing the poor victim, she wants everybody to feel sorry for her... She wants you to feel sorry for her... Why? Because she doesn't want to take the responsibility and/or guilt upon herself for the break up... Again, this is just HPV, not a big deal (except what she made out of it)...

In the following days, I tried texting her a few times, she didn't reply. I started to panic and get a little needy. I think I texted her to Skype me 3 times in one day or something like that? At the end, she finally replied and said yes.
>>>> That's a big problem, neediness... I know that panic too, unless you have a tight game it comes unexpectedly... Think about it, in general case scenario, the girl is pulling away from a guy, and he bombards her with texts and affection... She feels bad, and he presents himself as quite immature... When you recognize that you are needy, it is a big Red Flag because she can recognize it too, and probably way before you... Girls don't like needy guys, that might be the actual reason for break up...

When we got on Skype, she was literally starring daggers at me. Like, she legit looked like she hated my guts. First, I addressed the whole "why are you not texting me back" issue.
>>>> Neediness again, begging her for attention, requesting logical explanation... This is logical for every guy to do it, but girls don't like it... She already knows your cards, you are showing her more...

She said she's just been super busy cause she's traveling etc.
>>>> Excuses. A girl who is into you will always find time to text or call you. You know that girls are glued to the phone 24/7.... She justifies herself, and again there is the neediness... Red Flag...

Given that I texted her three times within the same day, I'm not really in a position to call her out on this, because regardless of her reasons, I look needy. So I just apologized for misunderstanding the situation.
>>>> I did the same but at work. Never apologize it outside of work environment, you look like a weak Beta... Once you apologize she will slowly shift you to friend zone orbital... There is no middle way, she is either your GF or she is gone... Red Flag...

Also, at the time, I kind of believed her. In hindsight, I think she wasn't just busy.
>>>> Nah, don't make excuses for her... She is an adult, she knows what is she doing...

She was also avoiding me because she associates me with the unpleasant feelings she has rn (more on that in a bit!). The rest of the call went really well. I got her to smile/laugh for the first time in a long time. By the end of it, she seemed to be at least ok with talking to me. Certainly, she wasn't angry.
>>>> Nah, don't make excuses for her...

Also, after that Skype, I quit texting her because I sincerely believed she was super busy all the time. Two days later, she texts me "hi". I text her back "Hi :)" . She responds, "Are you mad at me?" I tell her I'm not and ask her why she thinks I am. She says its cause I haven't initiated any conversations with her recently.
>>>> Good Game. If she walks away, don't contact her (like many guys do). Let her go. It's like a paradox - you want her, you go after her, but she runs. You let her go, you don't contact her - and she may come back, even just to find out what happened to the guy, suprised why is he not chasing? Remember, most guys out there, including seducers, are chasing in one way or another, the emotions are just too high not to contact the girl that you have feelings for...


Then one day, I text her asking her if she's down to Skype. She doesn't reply for almost 24 hours. I get legit angry for the first time. I send her the following text:
"So, you tell me you want me to initiate more conversations. So I try to get you to Skype with me. And you can't even give me the dignity of a response for over 24 hours? That's disrespectful"
>>>> Neediness and anger, begging for her attention... Bad sign.... You can be needy but never show it to the girl... Red Flag...


She almost instantaneously responded.
>>>> She feels sorry for you because in her eyes you just "Don't get it"...

She said she's been really busy traveling Spain
>>>> BS, she sleeps with the phone, all she can do is dial up your number... Did she do that? Nope... Remember, No excuses... Given all the above, more Red Flags...

, and she has something she needs to tell me, but she doesn't necessarily know how. She tells me she went to a doctor cause she finally can't take it anymore (remember, the entire problem is that she's worried about hpv lol). And also, apparently she had a wart. So she actually was developing genital warts. I ask her if she got treatment. She said she did. I ask her if they'll have any consequences.
>>>> She is making more excuses, she is trying to soften you up... I wouldn't be surprised at all if there is no wart...

Her reply was "emotional damage".
>>>> Yes. Emotional damage and pain - by breaking up with you, especially if you "Don't get it"...

She says she literally hates herself now, and she can't sleep at night. She says she thinks no guy will ever want to sleep with her again and that she'll never be able to have sex.
>>>> HA! She is talking about another guy again! Not you, but another guy sleeping with her... More Red Flags...

I reassure her that I would still sleep with her.
>>>> NO! She doesn't want to sleep with you anymore, yet you are still offering... She knows that you would love to sleep with her again, she is not stupid... Don't beg, don't be needy...

She asked me if I would actually *want* to. I said yes, ofc. She said she'll talk to me tomorrow (over Skype)
>>>> Think about it, like What would be such a big deal to sleep with her again if you already did more times? It's no big deal, yet she just doesn't want to...

The next day, we get on Skype. This was the worst one of all. The look on her face....pure disgust. Like I killed her child or something. Her voice...filled with hatred and disdain.
>>>> She is disgusted with you because you just "Don't get it"... She's decided that doesn't want to be with you, yet you keep coming back... She doesn't know how to tell you nicely, so she is showing you disgusted face, bad emotions, hatred... All bad Red Flags... She is basically screaming: "Just get it already"...

This conversation only lasted 15 minutes. The rest lasted hours. Basically, the gist of it was this: She apparently "talked to someone and she refuses to disclose who" and now she feels a lot better about the hpv thing. She understands that its nbd and she'll be fine.
>>>> Don't make excuses for her...


But she says she doesn't want to talk to me anymore until we get back to school in the Fall.
>>>> No! Give up on her. Let her go. Don't show any affection. Stop dreaming and thinking about her, and if you do (most likely you will) - never show it to her...

She wants to heal and also enjoy her trip, and by talking to me, she can't do that because she associates me as the face all that's happened. In other words, her mind has associated me with all the negative emotions, all the pain of the last month, all the misery.
>>>> Correct. She associates you with all the emotional pain, break up, hatred, misery, "not getting it",... I'm telling you bro, move away emotionally from her, forget her, focus on other girls...

At this point, I'm completely crushed. I feel weak and panicky. I ask her in a very weak voice....then what? Do you want to hang out in the Fall? Her answer was "I don't know." And that's the end. That happened yesterday.
>>>> But we know. She does not want to hang out with you. She doesn't know how else to tell you, she is frustrated. You are keep chasing her and chasing her bro, let her go... You are begging again, projecting weakness, you are chasing again, you are showing neediness and insecurity... ALL BIG NO!!!


I made a lot of mistakes:
1. Before all of this started, I was the one in charge of the relationship. I was the dominant one. But as soon as this happened, I started trying waay too hard to take care of her feelings and to make things easy as possible for her. As a result, she slowly but surely started to supercede me and take the reins. As you guys may have seen by that last call, she was calling all the shots. This was a complete 360 from before.
>>>> Correct and very good observation. LEARN from it for next time. Develop solid frame BEFORE the relationship, then keep it DURING the relationship as well as AFTER the relationship... You most likely got her with Alpha behavior, but then you turned to Beta... She tested you with the above Shit test, or another one, and you failed... Big Red Flag... Then you showed neediness and insecurity, only more crap piled up...

2. I tried to fix her problems for her. Clearly, she has an anxiety issue which needs serious treatment. And she needs to want to fix it. She doesn't want to fix it. There's nothing I can do about that. I didn't realize that, so all my efforts just backfired on me.
>>>> Yep. You show that you care, you show that you are too involved with her emotionally (needy), and the result is that you are basically gone... Remember, girls want DOMINANT man, a man who doesn't give in to her sweet emotions and silliness, a man who is emotionally solid as a rock... They don't want a clingy and needy boys that are chasing her around....


Parting Thoughts:
-This was a great relationship. Despite the rough ending, I would consider it a success. Because the 6 months prior to this, it was an absolute bliss. And I've learned so much from it.
- Even if she does come back to me, I'm not sure how I would continue to have a relationship with her. As long as she retains these anxiety problems, she will always be undatable. Because sooner or later, something will happen and her anxiety will get the best of her. Then we'll be traveling down this dark path again.
- I'm writing this post to cope with the unbearable pain I feel right now.
- It really eates me up not knowing who this mystery person who she "talked to" is. Ik he's not a guy she fucked cause I straight up asked her, and she got genuinely furious at the notion of it. Regardless of who he is, he managed to do in one one conversation what I failed to do for a whole month. Also, I strongly suspect that he's partially responsible for her decision to cut me off. And why doesn't she want to tell me who he is anyways?
>>>> Good summary. Always write good and bad things that happened during the relationship. Always write what you did for her - and what she did for you. One personal experience like this is much more valuable than reading about it thousands articles online...

-------------------------

So in summary we can recap:
- Minimal dominance, perhaps only at the beginning of relationship...
- Too much Neediness...
- Begging...
- Chasing...
- Missing lots of Red Flags...
- No Abundance Mentality...
- Not being able to walk away from her even when she is gone...
- Keep thinking that she will come back...
- Willing to accept her back... Keep hoping she will come back in the future...
- As a result, going through painful rejection...


How would Alpha male behave?

- If she wants to go, well let her go. Smile and wave, wish her all the best... Bite the pain, don't show it to her...
- If she left him, he would not contact her, he would not Chase her...
- He wouldn't be Needy because he has Abundance Mentality (simply other girls to focus on)...
- He would carefully observe Red Flags... One, two or three means nothing, but once they start piling up he would start pulling back from the relationship and start looking for another girl(s)...
- He would have another girl(s) within reach (because of Abundance Mentality)...
- He would be able to walk away from her ANYTIME during the relationship...
- He knows that chances she'll come back are very minimal. 10%? 5%?
- He knows that she already most likely slept with another guy... Very likely...
- He knows that he was disrespected, thus he would never take this girl back again... He stops hoping for any future with this girl...
- He shows minimal or none of his cards. She has to work very hard to find out what he thinks or plans to do, he doesn't give her any hints, and if she provokes him he goes cold... Very frustrating to her = very sexy behavior to her = he is this true mysterious guy in her eyes ...
- As a result he would still feel the pain from Rejection, but he would be able to get over it fairly easily...

Be tough, be emotionally solid, don't have mercy on girls that show you disrespect, be ready to walk away from her anytime... Don't show her your pain, shrug your shoulders and show her ignorance. Don't show her any cards, she doesn't want to know! Does being Silly and Cute ring a bell? Show her that she is silly and cute with her behavior and rejection... That's the True Game...ALL OF US HAVE TO PLAY IT, knowingly or not... Those who don't want to play mostly lose, only the determined ones keep winning...
 

Bboy100

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jan 2, 2015
Messages
1,107
Drck,

You're both right and wrong. Your argument basically boils down to this: I wasn't dominant/sexy/high status/masculine/alpha/[Insert term for proper male behavior here]. Everything that happened and all her behavior is as a result of this. I do believe that you're right to bring this up. Because as soon as the HPV thing came to light, I basically started acting like a lot more of a pussy than I normally would. I rationalized it by thinking that "it's ok for her to behave this way because she feels like shit at the moment. And I should do everything I can to accommodate her in her time of need." But in hindsight, you're right that I shouldn't be accepting disrespectful behavior from people, regardless of the situation. I will not make this mistake again. And you're right that maybe...maybe this was even a deciding factor between her choosing to stay with me and try to work it out, and leaving me.

In regards to this, I do have a little bit of a paradox that needs solving. By not calling her out on her shit, I allow her to disrespect me. But if I do call her out, then it could look needy because it can seem like anger, or like I require her validation. For example, when she's flaky or doesn't reply to my texts in a timely manner, how would I call her out without seeming needy?

Anyways...aside from that, I think that you're still minimalizing a lot of the issues. This girl was someone who had a host of emotional problems before I even met her. There's a reason why she as decent looking, likable, and an otherwise great girl, and yet, she remained a virgin who hadn't even been on a first date till she was 19. Part of it is cause she used to be fat. But Ik plenty of fat chicks who can get laid easily. The difference between her and everyone else is her emotional issues. And I still believe that although my behavior certainly didn't help, they are still the core reason for why this relationship broke apart.

she sent me a text saying she has HPV, and since I'm the only guy she's had sex with, it means I must have given it to her. She then cut contact with me for two full days. To be honest, I didn't think she was concerned about the HPV itself.
>>>> The thing is, if a girl is having some hesitancy about you, she will find ANY reason to break up with you or to push you away. As far as I can say, any health reasons are not uncommon at all. Think about it, if she really loved you (and women love men differently than men love women) she would easily overcome this minor health issue... Girl starts talking about lots of medical issues, it is a Red Flag...
Sure. Her problem with HPV was very unusual. But one thing to note is that she never loved me, and I never loved her (or at least, we never verbalized it). Also, as I mentioned in my OP, her anxiety about even small issues is through the roof. And also, she specifically mentioned before we had sex that she was particularly worried about hpv because she didn't get the vaccine. HPV was on her radar long before she even lost her virginity. Again...I'm not saying the way she reacted was normal. But I also think it had absolutely nothing to do with me.

Because unless i'm completely blind, she had no hesitancy about me. I was completely in charge of the relationship before then. She always differed to me, she was always smiling/happy with me. Not once did she refuse to have sex with me when I initiated it. Including in public. She texted/snapchatted me so much that it was at times, overwhelming. We had great, intimate conversations, she constantly told me how much she liked me, she traveled hours just to come hang out with me, she did me favors without me asking her to...and the list goes on. So I see no reason why she would randomly make up a health problem to distance herself with me.

In fact...

I explained all this to her. She felt a little better, but she was still worried about the small chance that she might develop genital herpes. She also feels dirty, like "no guy will want her anymore".
>>>> See? She is THINKING and TALKING about OTHER GUY. Not about you. Red Flag... She may already have somebody on the side... Remember, whether you failed the test or whether she was already thinking about break up (or both), now she knows that you are not Alpha because you showed her your cards clearly... She now knows you have a needy behavior and some insecurities...
She says she literally hates herself now, and she can't sleep at night. She says she thinks no guy will ever want to sleep with her again and that she'll never be able to have sex.
>>>> HA! She is talking about another guy again! Not you, but another guy sleeping with her... More Red Flags...
She told me from the day I met her that she was a virgin and she wanted to explore. That's part of the reason why she agreed to an open relationship in the first place. Months later, we were having a discussion about who we've had sex with in the past etc. I talked to her about some of the girls I fucked while I was in a relationship with her. She said she had been with no one other than me. When I asked her why, she said its because she likes me a lot, and I satisfy her. She doesn't want to be with other guys. So then I asked her why she's ok with the current relationship set up (open relationship) and she said its because she wants me to be able to do what I want to do and to be happy. She seemed very genuine as she said that. Effectively, up til now, our relationship was such that I get to sleep with whoever I want, and she's unofficially exclusive to me. No girl who is unsatisfied with me as a partner would get even close to abiding by these terms. Also, she was worried that even I would think she's dirty. Despite her anger, she would also always ask me for my reassurance. Several times, she asked me if "I thought she was dirty" and "if I would ever have sex with her again" etc. Additionally, she wasn't just thinking about sex with other guys. She had a fear of sex in general. Cause she told me that she was afraid to have sex with other guys cause she was afraid they would give her a different form of HPV (there are many different strains), and she was afraid to have sex with me because she was afraid that by having sex with me, it would reinfect her and prevent her from healing from her current strain (she read somewhere on the internet that this is a thing. LOL).


And sure, you could probably come up with an explanation for everything I just said which comes back to me not being alpha enough. And I'm not even saying you're wrong. I'm just saying that that's probably not the only relevant factor. I think that in the end, we have a lot of tension about our core beliefs about why women behave they do in relationships.

You believe that:

"All bad female behavior in the context of a relationship is as a result of dissatisfaction with the behavior of her male partner."

From there on out, you rationalize how each and every thing she does is actually a mechanism for her to express that.

Whereas I believe that:

"Bad female behavior in the context of a relationship is partially attributed to dissatisfaction with the behavior of her male partner, partially to her own issues/problems, and partially to a variety of other potential reasons."

So really, I think that if we want to understand her behavior (and that of women in general) better, we must first agree upon which of these views is accurate.
 

ProblemSolving

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
467
Firstly, to get an idea of how healthy the relationship was before the HPV drama, how often did she initiate contact with you and enthusiastically meet up for dates? This will tell you how well you've well you've run your relationship.

Next, the needy/chasey behavior exhibited after she got emotional about the HPV diagnosis will absolutely tank attraction levels and destroy relationships if it goes on for long enough. Yes, the HPV was a big deal to her, so it's understandable why she's freaking out, but you just made things worst by chasing after her. In cases like this, it's often best to let her know you care about her and empathize with the situation, but then leave her alone. She's going to hate your guts for a while and there's nothing wrong with that. Over time, emotions die down and she'll start to see the situation more logically and want to see you again.

Bboy100 said:
In regards to this, I do have a little bit of a paradox that needs solving. By not calling her out on her shit, I allow her to disrespect me. But if I do call her out, then it could look needy because it can seem like anger, or like I require her validation. For example, when she's flaky or doesn't reply to my texts in a timely manner, how would I call her out without seeming needy?

You don't call her out. If you do, then you are the One Down in the relationship. With you being the more emotional person in the relationship, you basically give her control at that point. Don't call her out, go live your life: meet more chicks, go lift weights, work etc. She'll come back when she's ready and she'll often be sweeter than ever because you're an immovable rock that can't be pushed around by her emotional storms.

I'd recommend reading all of the Chase's and Richardus' articles on Relationships. They will help you navigate the waves of drama that occur in EVERY relationship, so when the seas get rough, you'll be ready.
 

Drck

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Feb 14, 2013
Messages
1,488
You're both right and wrong. Your argument basically boils down to this: I wasn't dominant/sexy/high status/masculine/alpha/[Insert term for proper male behavior here]. Everything that happened and all her behavior is as a result of this.

>>>> IMO Life is more complicated than this. You can be a perfect guy, yet she may chose not to be or stay with you. Remember, it takes 2 people for the relationship to work out, not just one... I noticed here (on GC) that guys usually blame themselves if something doesn't work out. I believe that it is wrong. If she wanted to stay with you she would have. What reasons does she have to leave you? Remember, she is young. She may want to explore, she has many opportunities, she meets many different guys, and she has all the freedom to do so...

Sometimes we need to overcome our own Ego, the reality simply is that there are lots of attractive guys out there. Some may not know anything about seduction, yet they might be very attractive in her eyes regardless... I've seen many pretty girls with average-to-good-looking guys, they were just plain dummies so to speak in terms of seduction, there is no way they were smooth or skilled, yet the girls were just in love with them....

We as guys can contribute only 50% to the relationship, the other 50% is up to her... If she is not interested for whatever reason, it doesn't really matter how good you are as a seducer or what skills you have... You can maximize you value, however in her eyes you are just a guy, and the reality is that EVERY guy is replaceable... So you didn't have to make any mistake at all, it is possible that she simply wants to explore, or she simply doesn't want to settle down with first guy she slept with...

I went through rejections man, I could tell you stories... I am experienced, I have social status, I have knowledge, I project dominance, I am in great shape, I believe I am quite charming and IMO overall 'High value man' in our terms, I can recognize great vibes and I am not shy... Yet the girl(s) simply chose another guy regardless, for whatever reasons... By any seduction logic she should have chose me, but the reality is simply different... Such rejections hurt even today, they hurt for many weeks and they just won't go away... Many times it is the EGO we have to overcome, we did our best, yet the other half is simply up to her...

So don't beat yourself up, don't blame yourself for not doing enough... Many times it is not you - it is her...

"In regards to this, I do have a little bit of a paradox that needs solving. By not calling her out on her shit, I allow her to disrespect me. But if I do call her out, then it could look needy because it can seem like anger, or like I require her validation. For example, when she's flaky or doesn't reply to my texts in a timely manner, how would I call her out without seeming needy?"

>>>> It all depends on your overall Frame. IMO it is quite important to design Frame that you want to operate within, and then simply follow the Frame... Your Frame was weak, I am assuming that you started as Alpha male (remember, you got lots of knowledge by reading GC, thus your behavior is quite different than behavior of guys she usually encounters), but as a time went your Frame collapsed and you became Beta guy...

So for example, if you design good and solid Alpha Frame, you can call her out anytime you want and in any way you want. The reason is that in the background, you simply don't care much whether she stays around or not (you of course do, you just never show it too much). Add genuinity, e.g. honesty, good vibes, not being too asshol-ish, add some good communications, and also good emotions... She then feels it, and has to adjust her behavior to it. She knows that you will not tolerate disrespect, she knows that you can walk away from her, she knows that you have choices, so she is careful not to cross the boundaries that you set... She knows that if she crosses your boundaries you will walk (and you have to walk should it happen, otherwise you are collapsing back to Beta frame). She knows that you are the dominant guy with upper hand in this relationship...

Compare to average Beta Frame. Beta guy has no clue what is he doing at first place. He is afraid to call her out because he doesn't know how she will react, he is afraid that if he calls her out she will break up with him... She feels it, she feels his fear and insecurity, and she behaves according to it. She knows she has the upper hand, she knows that he is afraid that she will leave, therefore she knows she is the dominant one - and he is subordinate to her... She knows he is not the dominant guy he pretends to be, thus his value drops in her eyes - and as the time goes she will pick up ANYTHING that she can use against him, and once she is ready to leave, she simply will...

"Anyways...aside from that, I think that you're still minimalizing a lot of the issues. This girl was someone who had a host of emotional problems before I even met her. There's a reason why she as decent looking, likable, and an otherwise great girl, and yet, she remained a virgin who hadn't even been on a first date till she was 19"
>>>> Again, we need to overcome our obsessiveness, our EGO. The relationship is not 100% in our hands, only 50%... We may understand a lot, but we may not have the power to influence everything. If she feels that you are too good, too smooth, too knowledgeable - that itself might be a reason for her to leave. She simply feels that you have too much power over her, you have too much control over the relationship - which simply doesn't make her feel comfortable...

I am even thinking that guys shouldn't really understand much about the relationships... We should mainly focus on our lives, on building our careers, our physical fitness, our hobbies, our masculinity and so forth, while the girls should JOIN our lives by seducing us... What true guy, what true Alpha Male cares about relationships at first place? True Alpha Male doesn't give a damn, he comes, fucks the girl and then he goes his own way again, without worrying about consequences...

Think about it from girl's perspective. If she sees a guy who knows too much about relationships, she can simply ask: Why is that? Because he couldn't get laid for long time, thus he studied and studied... She knows right away he is Beta, though Beta with good skills. She knows that he is working too hard, he is trying too hard at first place...
But when she sees an attractive and masculine guy, who is clueless about relationships yet lots of girls are attracted to him because he is truly masculine, she knows right away that he is True Alpha... He is not trying too hard, he simply have fun but overall doesn't care much about the results... Just a thought...


"Because unless i'm completely blind, she had no hesitancy about me"
>>>> Be careful. Girls have their own emotions, moods and thoughts. Most girls don't have logical frame like guys, girls go by emotions, not by logic... Girls are naturally submissive, so when she is around you she may be 100% in your frame... But when she leaves and she is around other people, around her friends - her mood changes, her emotions change - and thus her mind change easily too...

--------------------

You believe that:"All bad female behavior in the context of a relationship is as a result of dissatisfaction with the behavior of her male partner."
>>>> I tent to believe more that guys contribute to the relationships 50% and girls contribute 50%. In order for guy to fulfill his 50% he needs to be dominant, have great fundamentals, knowledge, experience, Abundance Mentality and so on. If he doesn't have these, his 50% is not fully maximized. However, even if maximized all that is only 50%. The other 50% is up to her. Women change. They are different in their 20's, 30's, 40's.... They look for different things, different experiences and different relationships. Different guys.

In addition, all is also related to society. In some societies women have more freedom, more access to finances and protection by law, they can be more dominant and are allowed to have feminists views (such as in USA). Overall it is difficult to find a good woman in such society, the guy has to work hard on himself to get a better quality female...

In other societies women have less freedom, less access to finances, they have to be more dependent on men. They have to be more feminine. In such societies it is easier for men to find a good woman. The guy doesn't have to work that hard on himself, he is naturally assumed that he is already dominant enough....


Whereas I believe that: "Bad female behavior in the context of a relationship is partially attributed to dissatisfaction with the behavior of her male partner, partially to her own issues/problems, and partially to a variety of other potential reasons."
>>>> You are correct but there is much more to it. See the above, e.g. here women have more freedom to explore, they are more independent. They can go out and meet freely many different guys. If she is not ready for a relationship (most are not in their early 20's), she simply wants to experience with more guys... So even if you are a great guy with all the correct attributes we talk about, it doesn't mean that she will want to stick around you...
 

ProblemSolving

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
467
I would argue that the fate of your Relationship with your girl is 100% up to you. Everybody that gets laid often knows that getting laid is a numbers game - there's a lot of randomness that is completely out of your control. Relationships on the other hand, are completely predictable. Act weak and needy for long enough, and your girl will leave or cheat on you eventually. Act strong and lead properly, and your girl will love and cherish you.

Why do you think there are people on these boards who are constantly getting dumped or cheated on by their girlfriends, while others guys like Franco, Radeng, and myself (I'm sure there's others) have amazing relationships with women that treat us like kings? The trick is choosing your woman wisely and knowing how to balance yours and your girl's investment. Balancing investment requires an abundance mindset to pull off which is why a lot of guys fail at this step. Without an abundance mindset you will fail to lead properly and your girl will take control eventually. This is why before a guy gets into a relationship, he should be consistently dating and getting laid. If you don't have abundance, you won't have what it takes to lead the relationship properly and you'll chase eventually. Your strength is what drives a girl to love, respect, and invest in you. The more she invests in you, the less she cares about other men. When a girl is heavily invested in you, it doesn't matter if it's Channing Tatem or whatever celebrity hitting on her, she won't cheat or leave you.
 

Drck

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Feb 14, 2013
Messages
1,488
"I would argue that the fate of your Relationship with your girl is 100% up to you"

Interesting point, can't really disagree... IMO it comes down to overall philosophy of each individual, to what we believe and go for in life... Couple points though:

We invest into different relationships differently. A girl that you perceive on your scale 9 or 10 will take lots of your investment vs girl that is perceived as 6-7, or lower. The lower the perceived number the less we invest.

Paradoxically, the less we invest the more she is investing, assuming that she is attracted at first place.

In other words, managing girls that are at the same value or lower than yours is fairly easy. On the other hand, a girl that has perceived value greater than yours is fairly difficult to manage, it requires lots of effort. At the same time, a girl who is truly attractive KNOWS that she has many choices. She KNOWS that she can walk away from you and have another great guy within couple of days, if not the same night... Which makes it more complicated and difficult for the guy who is involved with her...

In a real world, there is not one great guy (so called Alpha) and the rest are only Betas. It works like that perhaps amongst wolfs but not humans. In real world there are lots of mixtures, e.g. One can be great Alpha at work and business, yet on the beach or in fitness he wouldn't even qualify for Beta. It is of course for benefit of each guy to be as Alpha as possible in as many areas as possible to increase his overall value, and many guys are already doing it, yet the real market is still pretty competitive...

...Which simply boils down that the hot girl has more choices, lots of choices... In society where she can walk away from a guy anytime she wants and hook up with another one pretty much the same day, it is not an easy task for the guy to keep her around...

Again, I'm not saying that it is impossible, I'm just saying that the guy has to work very hard to keep such girl around. Couple Beta mistakes and he is gone...

But the real question is, does it worth it? Does that ONE pussy worth it? For a guy to become GOOD with girls it takes long time to develop good skills and attitude. IMO, realistically it takes 3-5 years for average chump to become GOOD, and that is not only reading but mainly practicing...

And that's what I'm saying, all this effort, all these years of personal development, all these years of suffering and rejections - all that for ONE pussy that still have to be managed intensively in order to be kept around?

The question is, does she really worth it? What does SHE do to keep that amazing guy around? How much does SHE invest into personal development to keep such a great guy around? What does she bring to the table except pretty face and cute silliness?

It's of course matter of personal philosophy and taste, but IMO such guy is still selling himself cheap. He developed great Alpha attitude by hard work, he has more good choices now... Yet he is investing just into one girl, just so she stays around, while she does usually minimum, if anything...

From certain point of view, from point of view of Red Pill, such guy is simply still Beta, a White Knight who works very hard to make that one pussy happy... Should any break up happen, it is usually he who is hurt for weeks and months, while she is the one that walks away without any regrets. That's what I'm saying...



Another point, People grow apart.... We meet new people, we learn new things, we change our believes and mindsets... We change, girls change... Some faster, others slower, but we all change, our today's thoughts are different than our thoughts 5, 10 or 20 years ago...

She is pretty today because she is 22-25 years old, skinny and fit, hiding well all her anxiety and depression... But 5 or 10 years from now she can be easily 50 pounds heavier, anxious and depressed wreck, constantly tired and refusing sex... Is it the guy's fault? It could be, but WHY to take such responsibility and possible guilt upon yourself? To me it doesn'tmake sense, but again, that's just my opinion

I'm probably more of a Red Pill-er guy here than most guys... I've seen things, I've seen great guys getting destroyed by women... I simply refuse to believe that it is the guy's fault, because the way I see it, the guy did nothing wrong, he was just being a guy doing his best...


Let me tell you bro, once you spent lots of effort on personal improvement, once you become what others consider good, once you invest into that girl what you think is right, once you even love her in a way guys want to love, once you start trusting her - and she still walk away from you as if you were nobody important, she ignores you more than her FB friends she never met, and perhaps even bashes you behind your back to justify her behavior, well, that just fucking hurt... It's really your EGO that hurts, not her, because she is just being that silly, cute and innocent girl...
 
you miss 100% of the shots you don't take

Bboy100

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jan 2, 2015
Messages
1,107
I think that conclusively, what we can say a far a this particular relationship goes is this:

I fucked up in that I turned into a pussy and I allowed her to direpect and boss me around. This may have been the single most important/most influential reason for why this relationship fell apart. Or, it may have been one of many. At the end of the day, I don't think it matters. I think what matter is that I understand that in the future, I need to avoid that behavior. Because weather they were 10% or a 100% responsible for the demise of my relationship, those actions certainly did not contribute positively.. They only brought us down further.

As for reading Ricardus and Chase's relationship management articles...I've actually already done that. And if push come to shove, I'll start applying them to my relationships. But for now, I'm hesitant. I'm still looking to find my own way. A way which works better. Why? Because most of that shit seems straight up manipulative to me.

Ex. https://www.girlschase.com/content/opera ... ationships

...Like for real. She' not a lab rat, she's my girlfriend. I'm not going to "train" her.
 

ProblemSolving

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
467
Bboy100 said:
I think that conclusively, what we can say a far a this particular relationship goes is this:

I fucked up in that I turned into a pussy and I allowed her to direpect and boss me around. This may have been the single most important/most influential reason for why this relationship fell apart.

It was a good learning experience. Now you know how quickly chasing can ruin a good relationship, so you'll avoid it next time.

Bboy100 said:
As for reading Ricardus and Chase's relationship management articles...I've actually already done that. And if push come to shove, I'll start applying them to my relationships. But for now, I'm hesitant. I'm still looking to find my own way. A way which works better. Why? Because most of that shit seems straight up manipulative to me.

Running a successful relationship boils down to investment balance at its core. When a girl is chasing me hard, she gets more investment from me and when she runs away, she receives less investment from me. This balancing act is what drives girls crazy because they are never in control, but it's completely fair and they know it! They get rewarded for chasing and punished for running away. Most guy's problem is not that they reward girls for chasing, but that they reward them even more for running away - that's what happens when you're emotions override your logic.

"Manipulation" is a strong word, but one could argue if you're not doing the manipulating then YOU are the one being manipulated. By the sounds of things, you were in control of the relationship before the HPV drama, but the situation caused her to pull away and you chased after her, at which point, she began manipulating you.

Now that you've experienced some serious relationship drama, you'll be ready for it when it happens in your next relationship. When they pull away, don't chase after them trying to make it right (Rewarding bad behavior), just relax and wait for them to come back (Rewarding good behavior).
 

Bboy100

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jan 2, 2015
Messages
1,107
Running a successful relationship boils down to investment balance at its core. When a girl is chasing me hard, she gets more investment from me and when she runs away, she receives less investment from me. This balancing act is what drives girls crazy because they are never in control, but it's completely fair and they know it! They get rewarded for chasing and punished for running away. Most guy's problem is not that they reward girls for chasing, but that they reward them even more for running away - that's what happens when you're emotions override your logic.
Sure. I can agree with this, but I also feel like for this to work, all my actions necessarily have to be genuine. Maybe pulling attention away from her will work in the short term, but sooner or later, the truth will come out. If I'm panicking on the inside and all I want to do is text her and "chase" her, then even if I put on the front that I'm distancing myself from her, I strongly suspect that my nonverbals will betray me and the truth will eventually shine through. I think the key here is to actually want to pull attention away from her when she's behaving in an undesirable way. Not to use it as a "technique" or a "tactic". But paradoxically, if it not a technique or tactic, and it is instead, a genuine expression of who I am, I would not need to read an article on how/what to do in the first place.

...Which brings me to
"Manipulation" is a strong word, but one could argue if you're not doing the manipulating then YOU are the one being manipulated. By the sounds of things, you were in control of the relationship before the HPV drama, but the situation caused her to pull away and you chased after her, at which point, she began manipulating you.
I use the word "manipulation" because "relationship management" is in essence, using premeditated actions/behavioral philosophies when drama arises in order to trick her into believing I feel one way about the situation, when in reality I feel entirely different. As discussed in the paragraph above, I don't think this will work.

As for her manipulating me...sure, I guess if she read an article on GC or something similar and she managed to trick me, then maybe you're right. But I doubt that. I think all of her behavior was congruent with how she felt at the time. She wasn't manipulating me. She just had some issues with our relationship which caused her to lose a substantial amount of investment in it, thereby making me needy in comparison (i.e. she was no longer "sold" on weather or not she wanted to continue the relationship after he found out she had HPV, whereas I still was. This caused a natural imbalance in investment.)
 

Bboy100

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jan 2, 2015
Messages
1,107
Running a successful relationship boils down to investment balance at its core. When a girl is chasing me hard, she gets more investment from me and when she runs away, she receives less investment from me. This balancing act is what drives girls crazy because they are never in control, but it's completely fair and they know it! They get rewarded for chasing and punished for running away. Most guy's problem is not that they reward girls for chasing, but that they reward them even more for running away - that's what happens when you're emotions override your logic.
Sure. I can agree with this, but I also feel like for this to work, all my actions necessarily have to be genuine. Maybe pulling attention away from her will work in the short term, but sooner or later, the truth will come out. If I'm panicking on the inside and all I want to do is text her and "chase" her, then even if I put on the front that I'm distancing myself from her, I strongly suspect that my nonverbals will betray me and the truth will eventually shine through. I think the key here is to actually want to pull attention away from her when she's behaving in an undesirable way. Not to use it as a "technique" or a "tactic". But paradoxically, if it not a technique or tactic, and it is instead, a genuine expression of who I am, I would not need to read an article on how/what to do in the first place.

Additionally, I think that this would only work if she knows exactly why I'm pulling away/distancing myself from her. If she's confused and doesn't understand that she's doing anything wrong in the first place, this tactic will only muddle up communication and create even more misunderstandings than ever before.

...Which brings me to
"Manipulation" is a strong word, but one could argue if you're not doing the manipulating then YOU are the one being manipulated. By the sounds of things, you were in control of the relationship before the HPV drama, but the situation caused her to pull away and you chased after her, at which point, she began manipulating you.
I use the word "manipulation" because "relationship management" is in essence, using premeditated actions/behavioral philosophies when drama arises in order to trick her into believing I feel one way about the situation, when in reality I may feel entirely different. As discussed in the paragraph above, I don't think this will work.

As for her manipulating me...sure, I guess if she read an article on GC or something similar and she managed to trick me, then maybe you're right. But I doubt that. I think all of her behavior was congruent with how she felt at the time. She wasn't manipulating me. She just had some issues with our relationship which caused her to lose a substantial amount of investment in it, thereby making me needy in comparison (i.e. she was no longer "sold" on weather or not she wanted to continue the relationship after he found out she had HPV, whereas I still was. This caused a natural imbalance in investment.)
 

ProblemSolving

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
467
Bboy100 said:
Maybe pulling attention away from her will work in the short term, but sooner or later, the truth will come out. If I'm panicking on the inside and all I want to do is text her and "chase" her, then even if I put on the front that I'm distancing myself from her, I strongly suspect that my nonverbals will betray me and the truth will eventually shine through.

Sure, the first time you make a girl chase it can feel really uncomfortable or like a "tactic", but when you do it enough times, it just becomes part of how you operate and there is absolutely no denying the results it produces. Same with approaching chicks. At first it feels weird and uncomfortable, but then it just becomes part of what you do.

I can't tell you how many times I've wanted to chase girls to "fix" whatever drama, but I take a deep breath and look at the situation logically instead of emotionally, and I put the phone down and wait her out. The results are VERY predictable.

With that said, if a guy doesn't have a healthy abundance mentality, his emotions will override all logic and he'll chase her anyway. This is why when a girl pulls away, it really is the perfect way to reveal your true value to her. If you chase, then she's more valuable than you and her attraction for you plummets, or she chases and her attraction for you skyrockets. You got a little taste of that when you stopped texting her for a few days.

Bboy100 said:
Also, after that Skype, I quit texting her because I sincerely believed she was super busy all the time. Two days later, she texts me "hi". I text her back "Hi :)" . She responds, "Are you mad at me?"

She was wondering about you after you stopped chasing (the way it should be), but you got emotional and quickly started chasing again. When you chase your pet cat, it runs away, and when you sit still and do nothing, it comes to you.
 

Bboy100

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jan 2, 2015
Messages
1,107
Update:

So, about a week ago, she texted me. She told me she's starting to feel better about the HPV thing, her doctors in Portugal were wrong...she doesn't have genital warts but she does still have hpv. And she's sorry that she hurt me. I responded by telling her that we both made mistakes, but I don't think text is a good place to talk about it.

So we met in person a few days ago. I had no intention of getting back together with her, but I did want closure. The way the relationship ended seemed abrupt and unsatisfying to me. When I met her, she was in REALLY bad shape. She said she
- Doesn't actually feel any better. She doesn't know why she said she does in that text
- Doesn't eat
- Doesn't sleep
- Can't socialize or relate to people normally anymore
- She broke out in fits of frustration, anger, tears, self-loathing, blame and a host of other negative emotions more times than I can count throughout our conversation.
- She looks thinner. So I believe her when she says she doesn't eat anymore.

I can talk more about the specifics of our conversation, but to be honest, they don't really matter. It looks like the anxiety got the best of her. She's gone full blown "crazy chick". Also the only people she's told about this is me and her mom. In fact, we had the entire conversation in my car cause she didn't want to talk about HPV in public.

The next day, I sent her a long-ass text explaining to her that I think she needs help. I left her the phone numbers for a few resources she can go to. I also asked her to let me know when she sees the text. She never replied. I'm honestly concerned that she might resort to self-harm. She hasn't done or said anything to suggest that this will happen, but she seems to be in that state of mind. Thing is, I've suggested that she get help several times. In fact, that was part of my conversation with her. And she got very defensive/angry. But there's also nothing else I can do on my own. In fact, I doubt she even wants to talk to or see me right now. I plan to let the student counseling center or w.e it is know about this. Hopefully they can help her.

Why do I care about all this? Well...even though we've broken up, and I don't intend to ever get back together with her (unless there are DRASTIC changes in her mental health), I still care about her and it hurts me to see her the way she is. To be honest, ever since I had this conversation with her, I've been pretty depressed.

Also I think that, despite the fact that I felt like I was over her, I might not be. I still feel very attatched to her. Plus, I just hate to see people in my life go through something like this. It could've been anyone I care for and I would be worried..

Right now, she's going through worse than anything I can possibly imagine. Her life is living hell. And to be frank, I don't know how to deal with my own depression/emotions regarding the situation either. Cause its become much more complicated than a mere break up.

I fear there may not be a happy ending to this story...
 
Top