What's new

Stripping off the "good-boy" veneer

Marty

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Messages
1,554
This is a personal challenge that I face, which may not be relevant to many others, but I wanted to share in case anyone has successfully achieved this, or can offer pointers.

A lot is made of the “good-boy”/”bad-boy” distinction on this site—or at my age I guess it would be “good-guy”/”bad-guy”, in any case the implication seems to be that the “bad” variant is superior in terms of both quantity and quality of female partners amassed.

Now the difficulty I face is this. Deep inside, the “bad-guy” descriptor suits me well in many ways. I have always had a healthy skepticism for authority; I naturally reject arbitrary consensus and blind conformity. Where females are concerned, I’ve never granted exclusivity to anyone; I’ve overlapped my relationships extensively and taken an opportunistic attitude to romance regardless of existing ties. I still believe deep down that senseless rules are there to be ignored, just so long as you don’t get caught; from an early age I’ve had a tendency to challenge anything I perceived as tyrannical or unwarranted coercion—I recall specific instances of doing this at ages 5, 10, 15…

Yet, I was brought up “nice”. I attended a reputable all-boys’ “preparatory” school in 1980s Great Britain (not the same meaning as in the United States—this was elementary education) from age 6, and was taught such delights of etiquette as holding doors for adults, knocking before entering, and saying “please” when requesting an audience (e.g. on the phone: not “Is Jack there?” but “May I speak with Jack, please?”—I am conscious this will sound hilariously outdated to the American reader).

Later in life, having learned several languages and started traveling alone, I was actually corrected by locals for saying “thank you” too much, as if it were a point of language: they told me it sounded unnatural in their world. That opened my eyes a little!

Still, you can put the boy into England but you can’t put England into the boy: the rebellious nature has remained to this day, and I routinely ignore such niceties as working hours, occupational dress codes, volunteerism expectations, and the like. Social constraints is an interesting one… I will adhere closely to any social convention whose flouting would imply lack of character, decency, or social awareness; yet arbitrary rules that are there to provide intangible and questionable benefits for society as a whole, as opposed to protecting a individual’s liberties, mean little to me.

The point is that deep down I believe in kindness and respect for others, but I can’t accept regimentation and a hypocritical semblance of propriety as a substitute for that—so I’ll confront it head-on to see what’s really underneath.

In summary, then, as I have matured and increased in confidence I have chipped away at the “polite” exterior that was imposed upon me in my formative years as part of the socialization process. But my worry is that traces remain… I need to apply some kind of “paint-stripper” to get rid of those vestiges of superficial “niceness” that cause me to commit such heresies as pedestalizing, supplicating, and the like, on an individual basis. (The social element was never there, thank God—you won’t catch me friend-zoned or orbiting among other men, a habit I’ve always despised; and Girls Chase has taught me that I need not fear what I earlier termed “self-righteous” men, who instilled terror in me previously—I now recognize them for the ubiquitous “white knight”, annoying but ultimately harmless, and can ignore or taunt them accordingly.)

You could say: just develop the right habits in behavioral terms, then the mindset will follow. I’m sure there’s a lot of truth in that. But my chief worry is that I do not really have a “role model”. I don’t have an internalized image of what a seduction-appropriate “bad guy” actually looks like.

I’d hardly wish to take the path of the full-on villain, like Ernst Stavro Blofeld holding Tiffany Case incommunicado aboard his ocean rig. That doesn’t appeal to me. I don’t mind sacrificing a little in terms of quantity of female partners to be able to live in accordance with my own principles, which would mean attracting women to spend time with me of their own accord, and not “tricking” them into dates or bed or whatever else.

So can anyone suggest a clear destination, and a direction I might take to get there?
 

Franco

Tribal Elder
Tribal Elder
Joined
Nov 14, 2012
Messages
3,637
Marty,

In summary, then, as I have matured and increased in confidence I have chipped away at the “polite” exterior that was imposed upon me in my formative years as part of the socialization process. But my worry is that traces remain… I need to apply some kind of “paint-stripper” to get rid of those vestiges of superficial “niceness” that cause me to commit such heresies as pedestalizing, supplicating, and the like, on an individual basis.

I believe this goes back to what I mentioned before about how, as an older guy trying to learn this material, you actually have extra steps to take because you'll need to take two steps backwards and "unlearn" all the bad habits that are deeply ingrained in you at the moment and then take three steps forward once you've learned how to proceed. The only real way to do this is to push past the boundaries that you've established over the last few decades and try things that you typically would have never tried until coming to this website. Once you start seeing success with these types of things, it's very easy to change your mindset because you can make the connection between the changes in behavioral habits and your improvement in results.

You could say: just develop the right habits in behavioral terms, then the mindset will follow. I’m sure there’s a lot of truth in that. But my chief worry is that I do not really have a “role model”. I don’t have an internalized image of what a seduction-appropriate “bad guy” actually looks like.

Given that your British, I would really have to recommend that you attempt to model your behavior after a James Bond character (such as Daniel Craig). He has a very serious, confident style of approaching women and intertwines it with subtle, sexual undertones. If I had the accent, I would probably attempt some of this myself, but overall, his personality differs enough from my own that I wouldn't feel as confident attempting to mimic it exactly. That doesn't mean I don't support him as a role model for those looking to learn though -- after all, he is my avatar on this forum. ;)

- Franco
 

Glitch

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Apr 26, 2014
Messages
57
Good thoughts Marty, all the thoughts you have echo my own to some extent.

Granted I am a lot younger than you so my viewpoints will differ. Living in England at a very young age I was your typical chinese kid, instruments, good grades, top student and honour student equivalent. I did all the other things that you mentioned because that how society taught you, and it did make me very likeable and popular. However life situations including racism, how my parents lived before me (I always have in the back of my mind what they have done to allow me to have a chance of becoming what I want in life) has made me into a person that I would have to fight, rip and take everything out of life. So I maybe similar but with a higher sense of aggression?

I would suggest going for more of the decisive almost asshole demeanor. It'll allow you to see what you can get away with and it also helped me breaking through the pedestal. You can also consciously focus on an indifferent and non-judgemental approach which also allowed me to just go with it and see who this girls is, this may also stop with the pedestal.

It seems that being of an older generation the manners you have developed seem more in line with 'Casablanca'/Romantic. I highly suggest you play the asshole to some extent with emphesus on sexual undertones. Eventually this may help you refine your edge, dial back the 'good manners'. Then you can incorporate the romantic style you seem to have. Combine romantic with edge is my personal playstyle. Sexual and edge when laying the foundations, once baited and mine then the romantic can flourish. Being so young my commitments have been 3 months at most but most girls were overseas. I have to admit I do enjoy their thoughts on what their impressions of me were.

Even though you may despise it to an extent develop some of that asshole demeanor.

Note: Bond is always a good role model. Well I have to stick to Bond's East Asian counterpart. :)

Glitch
 

Nuncle

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Feb 5, 2013
Messages
172
Here are some examples of how you can shed the "nice guy" stuff without turning into a jerk:

Ignoring "advice" (literally ignore it, like you haven't heard it)
Blatantly and unashamedly repeating an action you have just been criticised/mocked for
Assuming that a veiled insult is a veiled insult, and responding to it, rather than assuming it's not
In fact assuming bad intentions behind any ambiguous action rather than assuming good intentions
Getting angry rather than depressed about others' shitty behaviour
Not reacting internally or externally to criticism, because you assume its a status play (which it probably is)
Deliberately refusing to bow to social pressure and then just shrugging when people try to say you're being unreasonable

Have just noticed that a lot of these are actually the same - fighting off others' subtle attempts to control you. So not actually being a bad boy at all, just defending yourself, although it will still give you a "dangerous", bad boy vibe.
 
a good date brings a smile to your lips... and hers

Eternity

Tool-Bearing Hominid
Tool-Bearing Hominid
Joined
Nov 20, 2012
Messages
606
See women as beneath you. If you put them up on a pedestal, they will have no choice but to look down on you.
 
Top