Hey guys, sorry about the late reply.
I wanted to make sure to get in the 5 openers with "Ok, fine...you win, you can talk to me" before I posted here again. One thing to note is that this time, I felt a lot less "pumped up" and a lot more calm and natural. The first time, I was super high energy and all over the place. This time, I felt a little more natural. Anyways, here are the results:
Girl 1:
Me: Ok, fine...you win, you can talk to me.
Her: [Laughs]
Her: I'm [Her Name], what's yours?
Me: I'm bboy.
Me: Its really loud in here [For a moment, I couldn't think of anything to say, so this is what I came up with on the spot.]
Her: Yeah, it gets even louder in like, an hour!
Me: Really? So you come here pretty often then?
Her: No I don't!
Me: Yes you do, I already talked to the bartender, the bouncers, everyone, they all say they know you on a first name basis!
Her: [Laughs] Ok, fine I come here all the time!
...I don't remember how exactly the conversation ended. But 2-3 lines of dialogue later she said that it nice to meet me walked away. I actually stopped her while she was walking to have this conversation. So I'm guessing she had somewhere to be.
Girl 2:
Me: Ok, fine...you win, you can talk to me.
Her: [Giggles and stumbles into my arms]
...I'm guessing she was just super drunk. Cause she couldn't even talk.
Girl 3:
Me: Ok fine...you win, you can talk to me.
Her: Noooo! [She walks away from me]
This happened on the dance floor. So I think she thought I was asking her if I wanted to dance?
Girl 4:
Me: Ok fine...you win, you can talk to me.
Her: Hi. [She walks away]
Girl 5:
Me: Ok fine...you win, you can talk to me.
Her: No. I don't want to dance with anyone.
Me: I said talk, not dance. C'mon, step up your game!
Her: Oh. Hi! [ She goes back to dancing with her friends]
I also did a few nonverbal approaches on the dance floor and ended up making out with a girl. As expected though, I couldn't really escalate it any further from there.
Final Thoughts:
One difficulty I had with this opener is that it seems really incongruent to approach a group of people who are chatting amongst each other, interrupt, only to imply that they wanted to talk to me. Because it seems like being that I'm the one who walked up to them, I would be the one wanting to chat.
Also, the venue was too loud, people couldn't really hear me. I'll probably try this opener again somewhere more quiet.
Troy, thank you for the ebook. I've only just started reading it. But it seems like it could be useful.
Richard, those are some interesting thoughts. I definitely hadn't heard of the visualization vs internal dialogue part before. What I've also noticed is that some days I'm far more "in state" then others. Like, this Friday, I was talking to this blonde- she was (physically) absolutely perfect. I felt no anxiety, I was relaxed, and I felt natural. Now, I have a date with her in a few days. Its weird how my mentality/confidence fluctuates so drastically.
There's some good advice here, but my 2 cents is basically that it comes from the experience of approaching hundreds of women and seeing what works and what doesn't. However, your learning process is definitely accelerated because of the help that comes from this site. What I would suggest is to learn some basic conversation techniques such as deep diving and baiting (the Spellbinding conversation series is useful, although I must say I only use about 20% of what is in it, I have my own style for the rest)... and then practice them on everyone you meet, it doesn't have to be a seduction, you can easily chat with the register attendant at the petrol station (late at night there's usually no-one there and it's intensely boring for him/her so he/she will be a grateful subject for conversation practice) or whatever.
Well tbh, its true, I'm sure my conversation skills could use improvement. But, I'm starting to think that its not a lack of conversation skills so much as it is anxiety when it comes to cold approach. Because even with only an introduction to a girl (i.e. we have a mutual friend), my conversation skills skyrocket and I start to behave more naturally. Of course, as we've established at this point, its just a matter of me physiologically getting used to talking to complete strangers. Eventually, I'll establish a feeling of "belonging" in that situation just as I feel now when I'm talking to friends.