3 points above you in what? Looks? If so, you're trying to reduce everything to a function of looks while stating that it's just a part of the picture.
Remember we're talking about men here. Even if we agreed on a rating scale of female beauty, the idea that women look at men's physical attractiveness on a linear scale is very unlikely at best.
I agree that muscle is overrated among guys, I wouldn't say that height is underrated though. I'm sure it is an advantage for short term flings but if I'm going by the most beautiful women I see and the guys they are with, height isn't some standout theme. Especially I see a lot of smoking hot latina women with short and very stylish latino dudes. Overall I'd say most guys I see with the hottest girls are probably around 6ft, but beyond that I don't see much correlation.
Why? I certainly don't look anything like a runway model, but I do have presence and a good intuitive sense of style. If you google men's fashion you'll come across plenty of dudes that don't look spectacularly exotic and yet have the ability to express themselves and absorb attention without saying anything. There's not a lot of guys around with that skill, and I think that's what they were referring to.
I don't have a stance, not like you, because I pretty much don't care, and the whole point of my style is to make women forget about societal conventions.
I thought you just said height was underrated, so it's overrated when it comes to looks now? So what is it underrated for?
Also what do the points refer to, why 3, and when you say consistently what do you mean, like every single time or every now and then?
Nothing concise about all this my friend.