What's new

Socializing  Does cold approaching not work in this day and age?

RDRChaseMember

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
May 13, 2019
Messages
58
It's been a while since I used this forum.

I'm probably gonna get downvoted into oblivion and have a lot of simp beta-esque assumptions thrown my way, but at this stage, fuck it.

I live in Scarborough and in general the Toronto area. I notice GC is very pro cold approach, but some of the members here reside in more European countries, so there's probably a difference in culture.

I spent a lot of years cold approaching. I have gotten numbers from it and even 1 date. I developed the skill to strike up a conversation with a stranger. But it lacks consistency and comes with a high rejection rate (unless you play a very high numbers game) But I've often wondered why cold approach advice is the way it is and the factors surrounding our environment that make it this way.

I'm very pro cold approach, but I want to go about it in a way that feels true to me. How I approach it is if I see a girl who seems very busy in the group, is in a rush, glued to the phone, etc, then I don't make a move. I have read articles on this website and many others before that said to just assume this is resting bitch face or "she may be open once you approach her." But the me back in 2019 who's trying to be masculine would approach it that way, but the me now who'd want someone to be open to them approaching and not because I took them out of their guard, is not something I want to do. In my experience, girls who didn't seem open to being approached, they often think about ways to keep themselves safe. I can't count the number of times I've had a great conversation with them, even flirted with them, then I get their number, send a follow-up, and then nothing happened. It didn't help that I was also friends with a male feminist who talked to me about how women feel "unsafe" in cold approach environments and often choose the safest strategy. Now I can't help but think "did they just act like they were interested in me because they felt that was their safest option?" With a mindset like that, now I'm likely to interpret even signs of interest as potential "Safety" armor. I've since then stopped being friends with him and am still doing cold approaches, but I'm not gonna lie, these experiences have been eating me up lately.

It got me thinking about the tips I've learned from this site a long time ago. The whole auto-rejection, being direct, emotional cresting, repartae and rapport building, creating attraction, approach high volumes, etc. I wonder if all of those tips were created to be successful with cold approaches when considering the factors western cultures come with this.

And what do I mean by factors of western cultures? Online dating and social media increasing general social anxiety, so people don't know how to have conversations with strangers and are more guarded than ever, feminism telling women that men are out there to oppress them, therefore take an 'all men are guilty until proven innocent' approach, which gets feminist to see men as potential threats (which could work against them in cold approach), the rise in political ideologies where people prefer to stick to their own communities and find someone there (where social circle game reigns king and it heavily depends on social status and reputation). There's also the fact many women get attention but many guys won't, this guys are often more active in getting what they want while women are more passive via incentive). When you combine all the factors together, then to the ordinary guy, social circle game is far more preferable than cold approaches (especially very true for those who attach themselves to a social political ideology like liberalism, feminism, and conservatism), even though I prefer cold approaches over social circle as I want it to be just me and her, no one else. It also creates a need for women to come up with strategies to protect themselves from strange men when they percieve cold approach as uncomfortable or creepy.

I thought it was just they would ignore you or give short, vague responses when you do try to talk to them (which at this point it easy to figure out). But I've also had experiences where women asked questions back, were enthusiastically engaged, sharing stories, showing emotion, even respond to flirting. I would try to escalate either with the number or some action. If it's number, then when I follow up with that number, I don't get a text back. If it's for some action, they show hesitance or LMR (which ik I'd have to work through, but I don't want to do that. I want her to want it as much as I do).

And in cold approach environments, I find most girls don't give signs they could be open or signs of interest in you. Whenever I have cold approached them, then just 5 seconds in they try to find a way to exit the conversation, or do a "faux engaged" conversation where they like the attention but aren't very serious about you. I won't let this stop me from doing cold approaches, but I can't lie that it's feeling discouraging these days.

Sometimes I wonder if it's my environment. I live in Toronto and I often hear they're very closed off and prefer to stick in their own groups (and surprise surprise, I hear complaints about how hard dating is from both guys and girls). Some of the cold approach guys here are mostly in European countries or even American countries, so maybe there's a culture difference.

My goals when it comes to cold approaches. I don't want to spend 1 hour approaching a high volume of women. I want this to be an integrated part of my lifestyle where I generate natural opportunities for cold approach (allowing myself more room to live life). If I see someone I like, the first thing I do is try to get their attention. I would first try nonverbals like a wave to get their attention (they ignore), other times I have tired delivering a personal compliments (ignore or they say thanks and move on, even when I have stopped to talk to them). Recently, I have now opened up with "excuse me, can I ask you a question?" which most of the time they'll say yes, but I'll use this opportunity to talk about something casual with them and embed it with a compliment.

My strategy here is to hold their attention long enough and make the conversation casual enough to reveal if they're into me or not. I'm essentially creating a situation where I have their attention and am holding it, but keeping my conversation style casual yet simple. Which means I'm not trying to build rapport or repartae with them, nor am I trying to emotionally cresten them. This creates a situation where I can see if they feel physically attracted to me enough where their body compels them to try to talk to me because they find me attractive. If it's easy for them to walk away, then they weren't interested in me enough and I already got my answer there.

I don't know if I'm asking for an oxymoron here, but I want to only deal with girls who make it easy for me enough not to need much game with them (which means they're naturally attracted to me from the get-go), but I want this to be consistent with multiple girls I approach. Don't worry about rejection, I've dealt with a lot of that already.

I also don't want to attract any feminist or women who thinks me cold approaching her is creepy. I believe my current strategy (where they hesitate when I approached them) would weed them out as the women who would be open to being cold approached aren't feminist types as they prefer to meet in social circles (cuz ya know, shared political values). The logic here is if feminist views men as a potential threat in cold approach environments, then the ones who are receptive to a man's cold approach with little hesitation isn't a feminist.

I'm essentially trying to work on cold approach skills where I filter in women I find attractive who also find me attractive from the get-go, filter out feminists, and who would be willing to date me seriously where they'll actually respond to my text when I follow-up with them.

I have mentioned in 2019 I have tried being that masculine man. By this, I mean being the one to make the first move, building repartae and rapport, always moving fast reasonable, being expected to initiate the date, the conversation, not being afraid to initiate flirting first, escalate to sex, read her mood and be the one to initiate. But (idk how much of a shock this will come to people here) I realized I have a natural feminine leaning personality and am attracted to women with masculine energies (and don't tell me to try fetlife or some BDSM shit, a lot of the people there are massive hypocrites with their attractions and rules, and the dommes are just their persona for a dynamic. They're still attracted to masculinity. They only adopt this dynamic because they believe in socialization theory and trying to fight the patriarchy, which ignores biological functions.) (**I included a note below this post. 2 stars means 2 notes) . I want women who are naturally masculine because that's how they naturally are and not because the patriarchy socialized them to adopt feminine mannerism and therefore try to stick it to the system by acting masculine, thus going against their biology. If they're naturally masculine, then they're going to experience natural attraction towards men who show more feminine personality traits like it's embedded in their DNA.

The only reason I still cold approach because I believe in fairness. If I find you attractive, I will come up to you and shoot my shot. Nerves will get in the way, but I'll lean into it and shoot my shot. If I get shot down, fine, at least I tried. In the same vein, if a girl finds me attractive, she should approach me. Don't give me signs of interest and expect me to approach you when I'm not even that into you. Grow a pair and express your interest in me, otherwise I'll put my attention on women who I find attractive in that moment.





*These kinds of groups form over political ideology where they believe in socialization theory, so all they did was end up putting together people with progressive views but on a primal level, still react very "conservatively" (in a sense women are attracted to men with masculinity, and the conversation of "rizz" happens but it's very underground because you're not supposed to treat women as "instruction manuals" or "see sex as a prize to be won, get to know them first".). Note, I do agree with them not to see women as instruction manuals or conquest, but practical tips on how to start a conversation, flirt, and potentially lead to sex should not be demonized. It's like whenever they hear discussions like this, all they hear is how to ignore a "no". Listen, you tell me no once, I full stop. I don't care if it's an LMR or you secretly want me to push forward, I'm not doing that.

*The current liberal groups formed around political beliefs, which means they find people who share their beliefs, not people who are naturally attracted to what's considered unconventional. When it comes to truly feminine men and truly masculine women, there are no groups bringing them together based on natural disposition. If there was such a group, I would've gone there in a heartbeat.
 

Chase

Chieftan
Staff member
tribal-elder
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
6,303
Hey man,

Welcome back.

Check out the Field Reports Board:


Only a handful of recent reports are from online or social circle. Most are guys picking up via day and night game.

We've got a couple of guys on here from Canada, I think. Plenty more from the US.

Funny thing is we get the European guys coming on here who say, "I see a lot of North Americans on here... I don't think this would work in Europe."

Then we point them to the European players and reports from guys picking up in Europe.

Now we've got a post here from a guy in North America saying "I see a lot of Europeans on here... I don't know if this would still work in North America"!

It's just limiting beliefs, man.

Cold approach is one of those timeless things.

It's why people are always writing books, shows, and movies about men and women meeting in some happenstance way.

It's the ultimate fantasy for men and women.

It's not going away until humans evolve into some totally alien kind of species that doesn't have the same mating triggers anymore.

Chase

P.S., my father met my mother via cold approach in 1977... well technically social circle-adjacent -- they had the same workplace but had never interacted before... he saw her and approached her as they both exited the building, chatted her up, and asked her out... her father had met her mother via cold approach at a bar in 1947 or 1948... not sure how my father's parents met but I wouldn't be surprised if it was cold approach.

The guys you are reading on social media who are like "cold approach is out now because of apps" were never really cold approachers... they're guys who were dabbling a bit here and there 10 years ago then got onto apps. At the same time these guys are claiming "cold approach used to be in" there were tons of people back then 10-15 years ago saying "cold approach doesn't work."

There will always be naysayers and there will always be dudes who dabble a little but can't get much traction... and there will always be dudes who go hard and clean up with it... plus some dabblers who dabble a little, meet a cool girl or two, and get a relationship going. Takes all sorts.
 
Last edited:

RDRChaseMember

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
May 13, 2019
Messages
58
was on track until the political bit 1/2 through and was going to write some stuff, but now I'm lost!

Don't be surprised if you don't get replies, you could have done with 2 as separate threads for this one.
I understand. It does seem separate.

The reason why I included the political part is because it's part intertwined with the whole thing. Thus, feminists think "the political is personal" which. I also hear "because of metoo, it's hard for guys to approach because they fear being seen as creepy, so no one does it apart from PUA."

A lot of people, both liberal and conservative, use emotional moments to bring people to buy into their ideology like it was a mission. The male feminist friend did exactly that to me. It took my own research away from his framework to realize he's operating from purely ideological frameworks. I can't tell you the number of times he tried telling me "the patriarchy tells men they need to be masculine, they cold approach, and end up making women feel comfortable because they feel entitled". Funny enough in the early stages of taking to him, he said he wanted to learn how to cold approach, but it took me a while to realize that was a ruse to get me to buy into his ideology.

This is why I included the political bit in my post.
 

RDRChaseMember

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
May 13, 2019
Messages
58
Hey man,

Welcome back.

Check out the Field Reports Board:


Only a handful of recent reports are from online or social circle. Most are guys picking up via day and night game.

We've got a couple of guys on here from Canada, I think. Plenty more from the US.

Funny thing is we get the European guys coming on here who say, "I see a lot of North Americans on here... I don't think this would work in Europe."

Then we point them to the European players and reports from guys picking up in Europe.

Now we've got a post here from a guy in North America saying "I see a lot of Europeans on here... I don't know if this would still work in North America"!

It's just limiting beliefs, man.

Cold approach is one of those timeless things.

It's why people are always writing books, shows, and movies about men and women meeting in some happenstance way.

It's the ultimate fantasy for men and women.

It's not going away until humans evolve into some totally alien kind of species that doesn't have the same mating triggers anymore.

Chase

P.S., my father met my mother via cold approach in 1977... well technically social circle-adjacent -- they had the same workplace but had never interacted before... he saw her and approached her as they both exited the building, chatted her up, and asked her out... her father had met her mother via cold approach at a bar in 1947 or 1948... not sure how my father's parents met but I wouldn't be surprised if it was cold approach.

The guys you are reading on social media who are like "cold approach is out now because of apps" were never really cold approachers... they're guys who were dabbling a bit here and there 10 years ago then got onto apps. At the same time these guys are claiming "cold approach used to be in" there were tons of people back then 10-15 years ago saying "cold approach doesn't work."

There will always be naysayers and there will always be dudes who dabble a little but can't get much traction... and there will always be dudes who go hard and clean up with it... plus some dabblers who dabble a little, meet a cool girl or two, and get a relationship going. Takes all sorts.
Thanks for your reply here. I'm curious to know what you think about how I approach cold approach and the 2 asterisks notes I placed at the bottom of the post? Ik my post is long and there was a lot I mentioned. You addressed a large chunk of my post which i appreciate, but with my new stated goal with cold approach and the type of woman in looking for, I'd imagine it would clash with some ideas here.

I'll also write up some field reports this year. Might as well if I still need to work to find my own way of doing things
 

James D

Modern Human
Modern Human
Joined
Jul 23, 2017
Messages
712
P.S., my father met my mother via cold approach in 1977... well technically social circle-adjacent -- they had the same workplace but had never interacted before... he saw her and approached her as they both exited the building, chatted her up, and asked her out... her father had met her mother via cold approach at a bar in 1947 or 1948... not sure how my father's parents met but I wouldn't be surprised if it was cold approach.
My dad cold approached my mom on the main bus stop of the island back then.

He gave her his business card and they agreed to meet the following day at the same bus stop.

She was excited to meet up with him.

The next day my dad arrived at the meeting spot and waited. My mom never showed up.

He hit on a few chicks on the bus stop (that part of the story my mom only found out recently and even after all these years, she pouted about it. Girls will stay girls) and headed back.

Around 1 month later, my dad, too busy with his business, succumbed to parental pressure and agreed to a typical Muslim arranged marriage.

At the engagement ceremony, they unveiled the girl and it was my mom lol.

They both laughed and carried on with the ceremony, without revealing anything to anyone. I bet it made for a good us Vs them dynamic.

After the wedding, she told him she flaked because she was too nervous and could not run the risk of one of her relatives seeing her with a playboyish guy.

Cold approach is there to stay indeed 😁
 

Bismarck

Chieftan
Staff member
tribal-elder
Joined
Jan 1, 2020
Messages
838
My father’s father met my father’s mother via cold approach on the street (day game). He told her: “I saw you from over there and thought you have a great pair of (legs? tits? my brother and I disagree over this last bit)”.

I’ll never forget the way my grandmother’s eyes lit up when she told us this story. My grandfather was 50 when my father was born. My grandmother was 30.
 

KJ Francis

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Mar 27, 2023
Messages
938
At the engagement ceremony, they unveiled the girl and it was my mom lol.
Amazing story!!


“I saw you from over there and thought you have a great pair of (legs? tits
Grandpa had some balls!!

Mine met at a dance put on by the ethnic community, but I did recently see his photo album, which had four full pages of small solo portraits he photographed of each of his girlfriends in the 1940's.


Scarborough and in general the Toronto area.
Have you heard of Mystery...?

He also lived in the suburbs (not sure which) and would bus into Toronto, starting with coffee shops and such, then nightclubs. He went about a dozen times before making an approach.

Now he spreads the gospel of cold approach pickup and says you have to find your way to the bubble of love. No one will miss you if you don't make it to the party. But you have to get up and go to where the women are.

Abel Tesfaye (the Weeknd) and Jim Carey are both from Scarborough.
 

KJ Francis

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Mar 27, 2023
Messages
938
Whoops can't edit.. Jim's from Newmarket... Doesn't matter... But hit the city man! Try Trinity Bellwoods park and the Eaton Centre
 

KnownUniverse

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
Jul 9, 2024
Messages
41
i think people meeting via cold approach was a lot more common pre-2015 than it is now. My parents met at a bar and i know quite few GenX's that met the same way. That was just the way you found love before social media now everyone is meeting online or through friends.
 
the right date makes getting her back home a piece of cake

RDRChaseMember

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
May 13, 2019
Messages
58
Amazing story!!



Grandpa had some balls!!

Mine met at a dance put on by the ethnic community, but I did recently see his photo album, which had four full pages of small solo portraits he photographed of each of his girlfriends in the 1940's.



Have you heard of Mystery...?

He also lived in the suburbs (not sure which) and would bus into Toronto, starting with coffee shops and such, then nightclubs. He went about a dozen times before making an approach.

Now he spreads the gospel of cold approach pickup and says you have to find your way to the bubble of love. No one will miss you if you don't make it to the party. But you have to get up and go to where the women are.

Abel Tesfaye (the Weeknd) and Jim Carey are both from Scarborough.
I've heard of mystery, but I'd imagine in his time, cold approach and pickup in general were more underground. But that's not the case in today's day and age. A lot of people are aware of pickup culture and they have very negative opinions of them.

They even have counter moves to categorize a guy as a "pua" and then once he gets categorized as that, his chances go from slim to none. The day and age we're living in tells a story, so at this point, it doesn't matter if mystery is from Toronto or not. I'm paying attention to the culture right now and now how it was back then like in the 1950s or how parents met through cold approach (which is likely pre metoo era).

Time and cultural norms play a Huge role here. I think before apps, cold approaching was one of the few ways you could meet someone. In the age of social media, if you wanna cold approach and get consistent results, you now have to calibrate on every approach which is way too much for me. If cold approaches before the metoo Era were more direct and didn't require calibration, I'd much rather go back to those times.
 

RDRChaseMember

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
May 13, 2019
Messages
58
i think people meeting via cold approach was a lot more common pre-2015 than it is now. My parents met at a bar and i know quite few GenX's that met the same way. That was just the way you found love before social media now everyone is meeting online or through friends.
If that was the case then I was shit out of luck. I started taking dating seriously early 2016. I guess I was too late. Goddammit.
 

KJ Francis

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Mar 27, 2023
Messages
938
Sad state of affairs when you think you cannot talk to strangers. People chat with each other in elevators and such every day.

The pua backlash is from guys spam approaching with really clumsy technique. Please browse the lay reports and see how it's done...

Good pickup does not look like pickup. It looks like two old friends.
 

KJ Francis

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Mar 27, 2023
Messages
938
If that was the case then I was shit out of luck. I started taking dating seriously early 2016. I guess I was too late. Goddammit.
Not at all man... People still meet at bars. Go anywhere that has people standing and mingling (not just tables of seated groups). Humans frequent these places to socialize.

People often exist in a balanced social homeostasis, between being open to social alliances and self protection. If you show you are not a threat, people will be open to you at social gatherings. It's human nature for us social creatures.
 

James D

Modern Human
Modern Human
Joined
Jul 23, 2017
Messages
712
Time and cultural norms play a Huge role here. I think before apps, cold approaching was one of the few ways you could meet someone. In the age of social media, if you wanna cold approach and get consistent results, you now have to calibrate on every approach which is way too much for me. If cold approaches before the metoo Era were more direct and didn't require calibration, I'd much rather go back to those times.
Of course time and cultural norms play a role.

And it's true that a lot of people meet online, whether by apps or sliding in DMs. Social circle is also still a major matchmaker.

But unless you live in a country whose laws explicitly forbids a man approaching a woman in public (in which case, move asap), cold approach isn't going anywhere.

I live in an Asian city where talking to strangers is super weird. You should mind your own business by gluing your eyes in your screens like everyone else.

People just don't chit chat each other. Super alien concept.

The only exception is at night, in bars and nightclubs, where everyone is drunk and feeling more social.

Yet, I've had zero problems learning day game in that city.

Norms do not favour a man approaching a woman, striking up a conversation with her and leaving with her contact info to meet up for a date (or leaving the place together)

This is why great social skills are a prerequisite for succeeding at cold approach.

You are by default breaking the norms.

Get good enough and you will succeed no matter the era you're in.

If Elon ever sends us to Mars, don't be surprised to see me walking up to a cute chick and telling her how stellar she looks in that astronaut outfit and inviting her for a meteorite viewing later that night.
 

RDRChaseMember

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
May 13, 2019
Messages
58
Not at all man... People still meet at bars. Go anywhere that has people standing and mingling (not just tables of seated groups). Humans frequent these places to socialize.

People often exist in a balanced social homeostasis, between being open to social alliances and self protection. If you show you are not a threat, people will be open to you at social gatherings. It's human nature for us social creatures.
Perhaps I'm thinking of it differently. I don't see bars as a place to cold approach. In fact, I think these are one of those places where approaching is okay. Alcohol helps with this as well.

I'm moreso talking about malls, transit, parks, streets, etc, when I say cold approach.
 

RDRChaseMember

Space Monkey
space monkey
Joined
May 13, 2019
Messages
58
This is why great social skills are a prerequisite for succeeding at cold approach.

You are by default breaking the norms.
Yup! this.

I often wondered why couldn't it be the norm to just go up to someone and just say you're interested in them, and they either tell you they're interested or not. But because it's not the norm, then being smooth is what makes or breaks it, hence great social skills being the prerequisite. If cold approaching was the norm, then there would not be a need for exceptional social skills.
Get good enough and you will succeed no matter the era you're in.
That's my major pet peeve. We shouldn't have to get good enough to succeed if it's not the norm, because that almost always means exceptional skill to be the exception to the norm. But what kind of world are we living in if great skill meant getting something that's basic as love, sex, and affection? Regardless of your success or lack thereof, I hope you can see how fucked up that is.

Now on that note, idk which asian country you live in but good job getting good in those countries. It's already hard enough in Toronto because you're playing by very unclear social rules, but I have been looking into Japan (being an anime geek myself) and the culture there is drastically different. It's actually culture there not to just talk to strangers as they highly value maintaining peace and harmony. If you managed to get consistent cold approach success in countries like that, more power to you dude! I'm actually curious to know what's your process in those countries.
 

James D

Modern Human
Modern Human
Joined
Jul 23, 2017
Messages
712
But because it's not the norm, then being smooth is what makes or breaks it, hence great social skills being the prerequisite. If cold approaching was the norm, then there would not be a need for exceptional social skills.
I guess this reveals a major mindset difference, which could be the start to solving the issue you're having, which I assume you want solved, if you made that post.

Yes, a certain degree of skill is needed. Perhaps not always exceptional but certainly above average.

While you view that as a curse, I view that as an excellent opportunity to learn and master a skill that most men are too scared or too unbothered to learn.

The high barriers of entry to cold approach is exactly why I love it. Once you jump over the wall, there's not much competition to enjoy the pretty girls.

I love that cold approach isn't the norm, for sure!

what kind of world are we living in if great skill meant getting something that's basic as love, sex, and affection?
You don't need cold approach to get those basic things.

You can opt for the more normal ways, such as social circle, online or buying brides.

It's just painfully slow and doesn't give you near the choice that you get with cold approach.

If you can make it work, or if you're satisfied with what you're getting with the conventional methods, then there's absolutely no problem.

But what kind of world are we living in
Nothing drains me more than these sort of comments.

I understand this isn't personal but imma sign off this thread after this post. There's too much misalignment in philosophies.

I'll tell you this much:

Irrespective of the kind of world I'm in, I understand that I was given a handful of hours to spend on worthwhile things, among which includes bedding beautiful women and having relationships with them.

I don't care the hand I was dealt or if the board game is biased in some way.

My time is running out. I'll do what I can to get what I want within the time that I have.

I certainly don't have time to wonder about why the world or society or women or whatever is the way they are.

Imma do what I need to do to get what I want.

Wish you well man.
 

KJ Francis

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Mar 27, 2023
Messages
938
Forget "the norm"... Look at a normal distribution curve. Do you want to be average, or exceptional? The average man is a frustrated chump. We may socially pair off one-to-one, but girls want exceptional men, and that means you will by definition have to be the exception to the norm.

Also I believe some of the day game originators came from Tokyo. I forget the handle but Teevster has referenced one of them a couple times.
 

KJ Francis

Cro-Magnon Man
Cro-Magnon Man
Joined
Mar 27, 2023
Messages
938
I understand this isn't personal but imma sign off this thread after this post. There's too much misalignment in philosophies
Auto-rejected from attitude dissimilarity lol, too low attainability of getting through...

Great posts on this thread... Looking forward to the first LR from Mars
 
Top