Before I explain you why your view is extremist and why it will not really help you on the medium and long term , let me summarize the history of PUA .
Basically PUA started getting a lot of followers with Mystery . This guy was a smart and realized a lot of interesting stuff . The main problem with him is that he has asperger syndrome ( basically a mild form of autism ) . Since he could not really relate due to being autistic with women , he focused a lot on how to " trick" them. More or less this was the PUA doctrine for quite a while , and a lot of people in the PUA underworld where actually autists .
Then some naturals started seeing the benefits of what the first PUA generation created , and using their natural understanding of dating added their experience to the mystery method, while removing other things that they did not like & were too much . This guys were Vin Dicarlo & another guy ( I do not really remember his name ) who basically created a new product that can be catered to most men in the world called the "Natural Method" . More or less GC is the legit continuator of the "Natural Method" .
Now coming to what you wrote , seeing things only as "beta" vs "alpha" and stuff like that is quite a limiting belief & extremist in the same case , and shows that you do not really understand women yet .
Let me explain you why :
High quality women are very scarce and in high demand , just as high quality men are . Since you do not really find everywhere a high quality women if you are a healthy individual you will realize that going extreme ( " my way or the high way") will not really work for a long period of time and this attitude will only make her distance from you , because well she is also a human being and wants to be understood . Just as you want the same
Again I am talking here about all kinds of relationships , not necessary a boyfriend - girlfriend one .
Till recently it was enough to be a provider let;s say , because women till like 50 years ago were just staying home and very dependent on their man . So more or less the paradigm till recently for a guy was : Provider = Sex . Don't take it wrong , the mail man were actually taking full advantage of the situation and banging all the bored staying home housewives , while you were at work . In the same time there was a lot of social pressure on women to marry young + not fool around otherwise everyone will slut shame her and basically without any means to support herself she would just have a shit life , because other guys would not marry her or take care of her ( unless she was hot )
Then something interesting happened , feminism started pushing in and women became more liberated ( I think that this is a good thing , just like all good things were moved to an extreme , that actually is more toxic than good ) . Suddenly it was not enough anymore to just be a provider to bang & have a relationship with a woman . This are the times that we live now , the modern man needs to be a lover & provider in the same time in order to "secure" the highest quality woman out there , otherwise it will just not work .
Trust me mate , being a good lover and securing a high caliber women & then she just vanishes after a while because you do not really have any provider traits will go mad & deepen your insecurities towards women